Free Speech
A safe space prioritizes emotional and physical security to prevent harassment and judgment, while a brave space encourages participants to engage with uncomfortable topics, challenge their biases, and embrace respectful disagreement for personal and collective growth. Safe spaces offer a refuge, whereas brave spaces invite risk and vulnerability to foster deeper understanding and dialogue. Some scholars argue that both are necessary, as true growth requires navigating discomfort, even while ensuring safety from harm.
This video explains the difference between safe spaces and brave spaces: youtube/v=pO_IfEviXBE (youtube/v=pO_IfEviXBE)
Safe space
- Definition: An environment where individuals, especially those from marginalized groups, feel secure from judgment, harassment, or discrimination. [1, 2]
- Focus: Emotional and physical safety, building trust, and providing a refuge. [2, 7]
- Goal: To allow people to be themselves and share experiences without fear of attack. [1, 2]
- Criticism: Can be criticized for potentially stifling open dialogue and not adequately preparing individuals for real-world conflicts. [1, 7]
Brave space
- Definition: An environment that acknowledges that learning and growth often involve discomfort. [1, 3]
- Focus: Encouraging participants to speak up, challenge their own and others’ biases, and have difficult conversations respectfully. [1, 2, 3]
- Goal: To embrace discomfort as a catalyst for growth and a deeper understanding of diverse perspectives. [1, 3]
- Key elements: Ground rules for respectful disagreement, acknowledging impacts, and challenging assumptions. [2, 6]
Key differences
| Feature | Safe Space | Brave Space |
|---|---|---|
| Primary Goal | Security and comfort | Growth and understanding |
| Approach to Disagreement | Aims to prevent or avoid it to maintain harmony | Embraces it as a tool for learning and growth |
| Participant Role | To be heard without fear | To speak up, listen actively, and be challenged |
| Underlying Principle | ”I will not be harmed here" | "I am willing to be uncomfortable and make mistakes to learn” |
AI responses may include mistakes.
[2] https://kapriconsulting.ca/blog/2023/03/21/creating-brave-spaces/
[6] https://mission.partners/theintersection/transforming-safe-spaces-to-brave-spaces/
[7] https://medcircle.com/articles/safe-spaces-vs-brave-spaces/
[9] https://www.wbur.org/cognoscenti/2021/11/30/censorship-free-speech-julie-wittes-schlack
[11] https://www.ascendhc.com/teen-rehab-blog/creating-safe-spaces/
[12] https://4h.extension.wisc.edu/brave-and-safe-enough-space/
Not all images can be exported from Search.