Religion in India
Religion in India is characterised by a diversity of religious beliefs and practices. Throughout India’s history, religion has been an important part of the country’s culture and the Indian subcontinent is the birthplace of four of the world’s major religions, namely Buddhism, Hinduism, Jainism, and Sikhism, which are collectively known as native Indian religions or Dharmic religions and represent approx. 83% of the total population of India.
India has the largest number of followers of Hinduism, Sikhism, Zoroastrianism, Jainism, and the Bahá’í Faith in the world. It further hosts the third most followers of Islam, behind Indonesia and Pakistan, and the ninth largest population of Buddhists.
The Preamble to the Constitution of India states that India is a secular state, and the Constitution of India has declared the right to freedom of religion to be a fundamental right.
According to the 2011 census, 79.8% of the population of India follows Hinduism, 14.2% Islam, 2.3% Christianity, 1.7% Sikhism, 0.7% Buddhism and 0.4% Jainism. Zoroastrianism, Sanamahism and Judaism also have an ancient history in India, and each has several thousands of Indian adherents. India has the largest population of people adhering to both Zoroastrianism (i.e. Parsis and Iranis) and the Bahá’í Faith in the world; these religions are otherwise largely exclusive to their native Iran where they originated from. Several tribal religions are also present in India, such as Donyi-Polo, Sanamahism, Sarnaism, Niamtre, and others.
I. Historical Foundations
-
Vedism (c. 1500–500 BCE)
- Core: Ritualistic Vedic sacrifice (yajna), polytheism (Indra, Agni, Soma).
- Texts: Vedas (Ṛg, Sāma, Yajur, Atharva), Brāhmaṇas.
- Goal: Cosmic order (ṛta), prosperity via rituals.
- Contrast with Hinduism: Vedism focused on external rituals; Hinduism internalized spirituality (Upaniṣads).
-
Transition to Classical Hinduism (c. 500 BCE–500 CE)
- Upaniṣads: Shift to ātman-Brahman unity, karma-samsāra-mokṣa framework.
- Epics: Rāmāyaṇa (dharma), Mahābhārata (incl. Bhagavad Gītā).
- Puranas: Sectarian texts (Vaiṣṇavism, Śaivism, Śāktism).
II. Core Doctrines
-
Metaphysics
- Brahman: Ultimate reality (impersonal/personal).
- Ātman: Eternal self, identical with Brahman (Advaita) or distinct (Dvaita).
- Contrast with Buddhism: Buddhism denies ātman (anattā); Jainism affirms eternal jīva (soul) but pluralistically.
-
Soteriology
- Mokṣa: Liberation from saṃsāra (cycle of rebirth).
- Paths:
- Karma Yoga: Selfless action.
- Bhakti Yoga: Devotion (e.g., to Kṛṣṇa/Śiva).
- Jñāna Yoga: Knowledge (Upaniṣadic insight).
- Contrast with Jainism: Jainism requires extreme asceticism; Hinduism offers diverse paths.
-
Ethics
- Dharma: Cosmic/social duty (varṇa-specific).
- Ahimsā: Non-violence (shared with Buddhism/Jainism but less absolute than Jainism).
- Karma: Moral cause-effect (shared broadly).
III. Scriptures
Category | Hindu Texts | Contrast |
---|---|---|
Śruti (Revealed) | Vedas, Upaniṣads | Vedism: Only Vedas; Buddhism: Rejects Veda authority. |
Smṛti (Remembered) | Epics, Purāṇas, Dharmaśāstras | Jainism: Own Āgamas; Buddhism: Tripiṭaka. |
Philosophy | 6 Darśanas (e.g., Vedānta, Sāṃkhya) | Buddhism: Rejects Sāṃkhya dualism. |
IV. Major Traditions
-
Vaiṣṇavism
- Focus: Viṣṇu/Kṛṣṇa/Rāma.
- Theology: Avatāras (divine descents), grace for mokṣa.
- Contrast: Vedism lacks avatāra concept.
-
Śaivism
- Focus: Śiva as destroyer-regenerator.
- Practices: Yoga, asceticism (Tantra in some schools).
-
Śāktism
- Focus: Goddess (Devī) as ultimate power (śakti).
- Contrast: Vedism has goddesses (e.g., Uṣas) but not as supreme.
-
Smārtism
- Panentheism: Worship of one God (e.g., through pañcāyatana: 5 deities).
V. Philosophy (Darśanas)
School | Key Tenet | Contrast |
---|---|---|
Vedānta | Brahman-ātman unity; sub-schools: Advaita (non-dual), Dvaita (dual). | Buddhism: Rejects permanence (anicca). |
Sāṃkhya-Yoga | Dualism: puruṣa (consciousness) vs. prakṛti (matter). | Jainism: Pluralistic souls (jīvas). |
Mīmāṃsā | Ritual exegesis of Vedas. | Vedism: Shared ritual focus. |
VI. Practices
-
Rituals
- Pūjā: Temple/focal worship (replaced Vedic yajna).
- Saṃskāras: Life-cycle rites (e.g., upanayana).
- Contrast: Vedic rituals were fire-centric; Jainism/Buddhism avoid Vedic rites.
-
Asceticism
- Sannyāsa (renunciation) vs. gṛhastha (householder life).
- Contrast with Jainism: Jain asceticism is extreme (e.g., nudity, starvation).
-
Pilgrimage
- Sacred sites: Varanasi, Prayag, river Gaṅgā.
VII. Interactions with Other Traditions
-
Buddhism
- Shared: Karma, saṃsāra, meditation.
- Divergence: Hinduism accepts Vedic authority; Buddhism rejects caste.
-
Jainism
- Shared: Ahimsā, ascetic ideals.
- Divergence: Jains reject creator God; Hindus accept Iśvara (in most schools).
-
Sikhism
- Syncretism: Rejects Hindu rituals/caste but retains karma and Bhakti.
VIII. Modern Hinduism
- Reforms: Arya Samaj (Vedic revival), Ramakrishna Mission (universalism).
- Neo-Vedānta: Vivekananda’s focus on experiential spirituality.
- Politics: Hindutva vs. pluralistic interpretations.
Key Contrasts Summary
Concept | Hinduism | Vedism | Buddhism/Jainism |
---|---|---|---|
Ultimate Goal | Mokṣa (union/liberation) | Ritual success (abhyudaya) | Nirvāṇa (Buddhism), Kevala Jñāna (Jainism) |
Deity Focus | Sectarian (Viṣṇu/Śiva/Devī) | Polytheistic pantheon | Buddha (non-theistic); Jina (Jainism) |
Scriptures | Vedas + Upaniṣads, Purāṇas | Vedas only | Pāli Canon (Buddhism); Jain Āgamas |
Social Order | Varṇa (caste) integral | Varṇa emerging | Rejects caste (explicitly in Buddhism) |
Glossary:
- Ātman: Eternal self.
- Brahman: Ultimate reality.
- Dharma: Cosmic/social duty.
- Karma: Action-consequence law.
- Saṃsāra: Rebirth cycle.
- Mokṣa: Liberation.
Comprehensive MOC: Vedism (Vedic Religion)
(c. 1500–500 BCE)
I. Historical Framework
-
Origins & Chronology
- Indo-Aryan Migration: Steppe theory (c. 1500 BCE entry into NW India)
- Phases:
- Early Vedic (1500–1000 BCE): �gvedic period (Punjab focus)
- Late Vedic (1000–500 BCE): Expansion to Gangetic Plain, composition of Brāhmaṇas/Upaniṣads
- Archaeology: Ochre Coloured Pottery (OCP) & Painted Grey Ware (PGW) cultures
-
Sociopolitical Context
- Tribal Polity: Jana (tribe) → Viś (clan) → Kula (family)
- Governance: Rājan (tribal chief) with Sabha/Samiti councils
- Economy: Pastoralism (cattle = primary wealth), limited agriculture
II. Epistemology & Sources of Knowledge
-
Śruti Revelation
- Vedas considered apauruṣeya (authorless, eternal)
- Received by Ṛṣis (seers) in meditative states
-
Oral Transmission
- Precision techniques: Padapāṭha (word-by-word), Kramapāṭha (step-recitation)
-
Ancillary Sciences (Vedāṅgas)
Vedāṅga Function Key Texts Śikṣā Phonetics Pāṇini’s Aṣṭādhyāyī Vyākaraṇa Grammar Chandas Prosody Nirukta Etymology Yāska’s Nirukta Jyotiṣa Astronomy (timing rituals) Vedāṅga Jyotiṣa Kalpa Ritual procedures Śrauta Sūtras
III. Metaphysics & Cosmology
-
Cosmic Principles
- Ṛta: Cosmic order governing nature/sacrifice (maintained by Varuṇa)
- Satya: Ritual truth (human counterpart to ṛta)
- Māyā: Creative power (later reinterpreted as illusion)
-
Cosmogony
- Hymns: Ṛgveda 10.129 (Nāsadīya Sūkta) - creation from void
- Sacrificial Creation: Puruṣa Sūkta (ṚV 10.90) - cosmic dismemberment
- Hierarchy of Realms:
- Dyauḥ (heaven)
- Antarikṣa (atmosphere)
- Pṛthvī (earth)
-
Deities (Devās)
Category Gods Functions Celestial Dyauṣ Pitṛ, Sūrya, Uṣas Cosmic order, light Atmospheric Indra, Vāyu, Parjanya War, storms, rain Terrestrial Agni, Soma, Pṛthvī Fire sacrifice, ritual ecstasy
IV. Ritual System (Yajña)
-
Ritual Typology
- Śrauta Rituals: Complex public rites (3+ sacred fires)
- Agnicayana: Fire-altar construction
- Aśvamedha: Horse sacrifice (royal legitimacy)
- Soma Yajña: Offering deified plant
- Gṛhya Rituals: Domestic rites (1 fire)
- Saṃskāras: Life-cycle ceremonies (e.g., upanayana)
- Śrauta Rituals: Complex public rites (3+ sacred fires)
-
Ritual Mechanics
- Four Priests:
- Hotṛ (Ṛgveda reciter)
- Adhvaryu (Yajurveda executor)
- Udgatṛ (Sāmaveda chanter)
- Brahman (Atharvaveda supervisor)
- Sacrificial Exchange: Do ut des (“I give so you may give”) theology
- Four Priests:
V. Anthropology & Eschatology
-
Human Constitution
- Breath Vitalism: Prāṇa (life force) > Ātman (later Upaniṣadic self)
- Post-Mortem States:
- Pitṛloka: Ancestral heaven (for ritual performers)
- Naraka: Temporary punishment (no eternal hell)
-
Absence of Reincarnation
- Early Vedism: Linear afterlife (contrasts with Upaniṣadic saṃsāra)
- Pitṛyāna vs. Devayāna: Two afterlife paths (Bṛhadāraṇyaka Upaniṣad 6.2)
VI. Social Organization
-
Varṇa System
- Ṛgveda 10.90 (Puruṣa Sūkta): Divine origin of classes:
- Brāhmaṇa (mouth): Priests
- Kṣatriya (arms): Rulers/warriors
- Vaiśya (thighs): Producers
- Śūdra (feet): Servants
- Ṛgveda 10.90 (Puruṣa Sūkta): Divine origin of classes:
-
Gender Roles
- Women as ritual partners (saha-dharmiṇī)
- Female seers: Brahmavādinīs (e.g., Ghosā, Lopāmudrā)
VII. Contrasts with Contemporary Traditions
Concept | Vedism | Early Upaniṣads | Buddhism | Jainism |
---|---|---|---|---|
Ultimate Goal | Abhyudaya (prosperity) | Mokṣa (liberation) | Nirvāṇa (cessation) | Kevala Jñāna (omniscience) |
Afterlife | Linear (Pitṛloka) | Cyclic rebirth (saṃsāra) | Rebirth in 6 realms | Atomic soul (jīva) transmigration |
Authority | Vedic mantras | Experiential knowledge | Buddha’s enlightenment | Tīrthaṅkara teachings |
Ritual Focus | Fire sacrifice (yajña) | Internalized meditation | Rejects Vedic sacrifices | Extreme asceticism (tapas) |
Divinity | Polytheistic henotheism | Impersonal Brahman | Non-theistic | Atheistic (no creator god) |
VIII. Philosophical Evolution
-
Brāhmaṇas (900–700 BCE)
- Ritual Symbolism: Adhyātma (micro-macrocosm links)
- e.g., Agnicayana altar = cosmic Puruṣa
- Power of Speech: Vāc (sacred utterance) as creative force
- Ritual Symbolism: Adhyātma (micro-macrocosm links)
-
Āraṇyakas (700–500 BCE)
- “Forest Treatises”: Transition to internalized rituals
- Proto-Yoga: Prāṇāgnihotra (mental fire offering)
IX. Legacy & Transformation
-
Upaniṣadic Shift
- From external sacrifice → internal knowledge (jñāna-kāṇḍa)
- Key doctrines: Ātman-Brahman, Karma-Saṃsāra-Mokṣa
-
Survivals in Hinduism
- Vedic mantras in modern rites (e.g., marriage, death)
- Revival movements (Arya Samaj)
-
Critiques by Śramaṇa Traditions
- Buddhist Tevijja Sutta: Rejects Vedic path to union with Brahmā
- Jain emphasis on ahiṃsā vs. animal sacrifice
Key Terms:
- Yajña: Sacrificial ritual
- Ṛta: Cosmic order
- Devā: Deity (root div = “to shine”)
- Mantra: Sacred formulaic utterance
- Homa: Fire offering
Comprehensive MOC: Classical Hinduism
(c. 500 BCE – 1200 CE)
Contrasts with Vedism, Buddhism, Jainism, and foreshadows Modern Hinduism
I. Historical Framework
-
Periodization & Context
- Formative Phase (500–200 BCE): Upaniṣadic shift; rise of Mahājanapadas; Mauryan Empire
- Golden Age (200 BCE–500 CE): Gupta Empire; Sanskrit literature flourishes
- Expansion Phase (500–1200 CE): Regional kingdoms; Bhakti movements; temple-building
- Contrast with Vedism: Replaced ritual-centric Vedism with diverse paths (bhakti/jñāna/karma).
-
Key Catalysts
- Urbanization along Gangetic Plain
- Śramaṇa movements (Buddhism/Jainism) challenging Vedic authority
- Integration of non-Vedic deities (e.g., Śiva/Viṣṇu) and folk traditions
II. Sacred Literature
Category | Key Texts | Significance | Contrast |
---|---|---|---|
Śruti (Revealed) | Principal Upaniṣads (13) | Foundation for Vedānta philosophy | Vedism: Limited to Saṃhitās/Brāhmaṇas |
Smṛti (Remembered) | |||
- Itihāsa | Mahābhārata (incl. Bhagavad Gītā), Rāmāyaṇa | Dharma exemplars; synthesis of yoga paths | Buddhism: Rejects epics as authoritative |
- Purāṇas | 18 Mahāpurāṇas (e.g., Viṣṇu, Śiva) | Sectarian theology; cosmology; bhakti focus | Vedism: No equivalent texts |
- Dharmaśāstras | Manusmṛti, Yājñavalkyasmṛti | Codified varṇāśrama dharma | Buddhism: Rejects caste hierarchy |
Philosophical | Brahma Sūtras, Sāṃkhya Kārikā, Yoga Sūtras | Systematic darśanas | Jainism: Focuses on own āgamas |
III. Core Doctrines
-
Metaphysics
- Brahman-Ātman: Unity (Advaita) / Qualified non-duality (Viśiṣṭādvaita) / Dualism (Dvaita)
- Prakṛti-Puruṣa: Sāṃkhya dualism (material vs. conscious principles)
- Contrast with Buddhism: Rejects anattā (no-self); affirms eternal ātman.
- Contrast with Vedism: Transcends nature deities (Indra/Agni) for cosmic principles.
-
Soteriology
- Mokṣa: Liberation from saṃsāra via:
- Jñāna Yoga (knowledge)
- Bhakti Yoga (devotion)
- Karma Yoga (selfless action)
- Contrast with Jainism: Less emphasis on extreme asceticism; householder-friendly paths.
- Mokṣa: Liberation from saṃsāra via:
-
Cosmology
- Cyclic time: Yugas (Kṛta → Kali) and cosmic dissolution (pralaya)
- Multilayered universe: 14 lokas (realms)
- Contrast with Vedism: Replaces tripartite cosmos (dyauḥ-antarikṣa-pṛthvī) with complex Purāṇic models.
IV. Major Traditions
-
Vaiṣṇavism
- Theology: Viṣṇu as supreme; 10 avatāras (Rāma, Kṛṣṇa)
- Sects: Pāñcarātra (tantric), Vaikhānasa (Vedic continuity)
- Contrast: Avatāra concept absent in Vedism/Buddhism.
-
Śaivism
- Forms: Rudra (Vedic remnant) → Śiva as destroyer-regenerator
- Schools: Pāśupata (ascetic), Kāpālika (transgressive), Kashmir Śaivism (monistic)
- Contrast with Jainism: Accepts creator deity vs. Jain atheism.
-
Śāktism
- Devi Theology: Devī as Prakṛti (material force); Mahādevī (Durgā/Kālī)
- Tantra: Ritual use of maṇḍalas, mantras, yantras
- Contrast: Goddess supremacy contrasts with Vedic subordinate goddesses (Uṣas).
V. Philosophical Systems (Ṣaḍ-Darśanas)
School | Founder/Text | Core Tenet | Contrast |
---|---|---|---|
Vedānta | Bādarāyaṇa (Brahma Sūtra) | Brahman-ātman identity | Buddhism: Rejects permanent reality (śūnyatā) |
Sāṃkhya | Kapila (Sāṃkhya Kārikā) | Dualism: puruṣa (consciousness) vs. prakṛti | Jainism: Plural souls (jīvas) |
Yoga | Patañjali (Yoga Sūtras) | 8-limbed path (aṣṭāṅga) to kaivalya | Buddhist Yoga: Similar meditation techniques |
Nyāya | Gautama (Nyāya Sūtras) | Logic-based proof of God | Vedism: No formal epistemology |
Vaiśeṣika | Kaṇāda (Vaiśeṣika Sūtra) | Atomism; 6 categories of reality | |
Mīmāṃsā | Jaimini (Mīmāṃsā Sūtra) | Ritual exegesis; apauruṣeya Vedas | Rejects Upaniṣadic mokṣa focus |
VI. Social Structure
-
Varṇāśrama Dharma
- Varṇa: Brāhmaṇa (priests), Kṣatriya (warriors), Vaiśya (traders), Śūdra (servants)
- Āśramas: Brahmacarya (student), Gṛhastha (householder), Vānaprastha (hermit), Sannyāsa (renunciate)
- Contrast with Buddhism/Jainism: Explicit rejection of caste (e.g., Buddha’s sangha open to all).
-
Gender Dynamics
- Idealized femininity: Sītā (devotion) vs. Draupadī (agency) in epics
- Tantric Śāktism: Female gurus and ritual equality
- Contrast with Vedism: Vedic female ṛṣis (e.g., Ghosā) decline in Classical era.
VII. Rituals & Practices
-
Domestic Worship
- Pūjā: Icon (mūrti) worship with offerings (flowers/food)
- Saṃskāras: 16 life-cycle rites (e.g., upanayana, vivāha)
-
Temple Culture
- Architecture: Nagara (North), Drāviḍa (South), Vesara (Hybrid) styles
- Function: Hub for bhakti, art, and social life
-
Pilgrimage (Tīrtha-yātrā)
- Sacred geography: Vārāṇasī (Śiva), Prayāga (trivenī saṅgama), Mathurā (Kṛṣṇa)
- Contrast with Vedism: Replaces fire-altars (yajña) with temple-centric worship.
VIII. Art & Iconography
-
Sacred Imagery
- Viṣṇu: Cakra (discus), Śaṅkha (conch), reclining on Ananta
- Śiva: Naṭarāja (cosmic dance), liṅga, trident
- Devi: Durgā slaying Mahiṣāsura, Kālī standing on Śiva
-
Narrative Art
- Epics/Purāṇas in temple reliefs (e.g., Mahābalipuram’s “Descent of the Ganges”)
- Contrast with Buddhism: Hindu art emphasizes deity multiplicity vs. Buddha-centric icons.
IX. Interactions with Other Traditions
-
Buddhism
- Debates: Hindu-Buddhist dialogues at Nālandā/Vikramaśīla
- Syncretism: Adoption of Buddhist meditation (dhyāna) into Yoga
- Critique: Mīmāṃsā rejection of Buddhist impermanence (anitya)
-
Jainism
- Shared: Ahiṃsā ideals, karma doctrine
- Divergence: Jains reject creator God; Hindus absorb Jain figures (e.g., Ṛṣabha as Viṣṇu avatāra)
X. Contrasts with Modern Hinduism
Aspect | Classical Hinduism | Modern Hinduism |
---|---|---|
Authority | Śruti/Smṛti texts central | Reformers (e.g., Vivekananda) + gurus |
Social Structure | Rigid varṇāśrama | Caste challenged; urban mobility |
Bhakti Focus | Theistic (saguna Brahman) | Includes universalist/non-theistic forms |
Global Presence | Indian subcontinent | Worldwide diaspora; interfaith dialogue |
Key Terms:
- Bhakti: Devotion to personal deity
- Varṇāśrama: Caste-life stage system
- Mokṣa: Liberation from rebirth
- Saguna/Nirguna Brahman: God with/without attributes
- Darśana: Philosophical “viewpoint”
Comprehensive MOC: Metaphysics in Indian Philosophy
I. Ontology: Nature of Reality
-
Hindu Traditions
- Vedism (1500–500 BCE):
- Upaniṣadic Shift (800–500 BCE):
- Brahman: Impersonal absolute reality (vs. Vedic personal gods).
- Ātman: Eternal self replacing ritual-bound prāṇa (Vedic self → Upaniṣadic self).
- Classical Systems:
-
Buddhism:
- Śūnyatā: Emptiness (no inherent existence; contrasts with Brahman/Ātman).
- Pratītyasamutpāda: Dependent origination (rejects permanent substances).
- Contrast: Denies Ātman (Anattā doctrine).
-
Jainism:
- Anekāntavāda: Reality has infinite aspects (vs. Hindu/Buddhist monism/emptiness).
- Dravya: 6 eternal substances (e.g., Jīva soul, Pudgala matter).
II. Cosmology: Origin/Structure of Universe
-
Hindu Frameworks:
-
Buddhism:
-
Jainism:
- Eternal Loka: Uncreated universe with Mount Meru axis.
- Contrast: Rejects cosmic dissolution (vs. Hindu pralaya).
III. Theology: Divine Principles
Tradition | Concept | Key Features | Contrasts |
---|---|---|---|
Vedism | [[Deva (Hinduism) | Devas]] | Nature deities (Indra=rain, Agni=fire) |
Classical | Ishvara | Personal God (Viṣṇu/Śiva) in Saguna Brahman | Vedism lacks sustained monotheism |
Buddhism | Non-theism | Buddha as teacher, not creator | Rejects Śruti authority |
Jainism | [[Arihant (Jainism) | Arihant]] | Liberated soul, not omnipotent creator |
IV. Nature of Self (Ātman vs. Non-Self)
-
Evolution in Hinduism:
- Vedism:
- No unified self; ritual-bound prāṇa → Pitṛloka (ancestral heaven).
- Upaniṣadic Revolution:
- Classical Debates:
- Advaita: Ātman-Brahman non-duality (Adi Shankara).
- Dvaita: Eternal soul-God distinction (Madhvacharya).
- Vedism:
-
Buddhist Counterpoint:
-
Jain Synthesis:
- Eternal but plural Jīvas (souls) trapped by karma-matter.
V. Causality & Time
-
Shared Foundations:
- Karma: Moral cause-effect (but differing mechanisms):
- Hindu: Ritual/ethical actions → rebirth quality.
- Buddhist: Intent (cetanā) shapes rebirth.
- Jain: Karma as physical particles binding soul.
- Cyclic Time:
- Hindu: Yuga cycles.
- Buddhist: Kalpas with no beginning.
- Jain: Eternal cosmic wheel (Kālachakra).
- Karma: Moral cause-effect (but differing mechanisms):
-
Vedic → Classical Shift:
VI. Epistemology-Metaphysics Links
VII. Key Evolutionary Shifts
Concept | Vedism | Upaniṣadic | Classical | Śramaṇa Traditions |
---|---|---|---|---|
Ultimate Reality | Ṛta (cosmic order) | Brahman (impersonal) | Ishvara (personal God) | Śūnyatā (Buddhism) |
Selfhood | Ritual-bound prāṇa | Cosmic Ātman | Sect-specific interpretations | Anattā (Buddhism) |
Afterlife | Linear Pitṛloka | Cyclic Samsāra | Mokṣa liberation | Nirvāṇa/Kevala Jñāna |
Causality | Sacrifice → cosmic balance | Karma ethics | Dharma-governed action | Intent-based karma |
Core Backlinks:
Contrasts Summary
Issue | Hinduism | Buddhism | Jainism |
---|---|---|---|
Ultimate Reality | Brahman/Ishvara (unified/dual) | Dependent arising (śūnyatā) | Eternal plural substances |
Self | Eternal ātman (mostly) | No-self (anattā) | Eternal jīva (soul) |
Creator God | Present (in most schools) | Absent | Absent |
Time | Cyclic with dissolution | Beginningless cycles | Eternal universe |
Karma Mechanism | Ethical-ritual causes rebirth | Mental intent drives rebirth | Physical particles bind soul |
Comprehensive MOC: Soteriology in Indian Traditions
I. Hindu Soteriology
-
Vedism (1500–500 BCE)
-
Upaniṣadic Revolution (800–500 BCE)
- Goal: Mokṣa (liberation from Saṃsāra) via Self-Brahman realization.
- Mechanism: Jñāna Yoga (knowledge) > ritual; karma as binding force.
- Key Shift: Ritual success → Inner wisdom (Bṛhadāraṇyaka Upaniṣad 4.4.5).
-
Classical Paths (Yogas)
Path Mechanism Textual Basis Metaphysical Link Jñāna Yoga Discernment (viveka) of real vs. unreal Vivekachūḍāmaṇi Advaita Vedānta (non-duality) Bhakti Yoga Devotion to Ishvara (Viṣṇu/Śiva) Bhagavad Gītā Ch. 12 Saguna Brahman (God with form) Karma Yoga Selfless action (niṣkāma karma) Bhagavad Gītā Ch. 3 Dharma as cosmic duty Rāja Yoga Meditation (dhyāna) + ethical discipline Yoga Sūtras Puruṣa-Prakṛti dualism -
Vedāntic Variations
II. Buddhist Soteriology
-
Core Framework: Four Noble Truths
- Dukkha (suffering) → Samudaya (craving) → Nirodha (cessation) → Magga (path).
-
Path to Nirvāṇa
- Noble Eightfold Path:
- Wisdom: Right View, Right Intention.
- Ethics: Right Speech, Right Action, Right Livelihood.
- Meditation: Right Effort, Right Mindfulness, Right Concentration.
- Mechanism: Extinguish craving (Taṇhā) via insight into Anattā (no-self) and Śūnyatā (emptiness).
- Noble Eightfold Path:
-
Schools Contrast
Tradition Goal Path Emphasis Theravāda Arahantship (self-liberation) Vipassanā (insight) + Sīla (morality) Mahāyāna Buddhahood for all beings Bodhicitta + compassion (Karuṇā) Vajrayāna Swift enlightenment Tantric rituals + guru devotion
III. Jain Soteriology
- Goal: Kevala Jñāna (omniscience) → liberation from Saṃsāra.
- Path: Ratnatraya
- Samyak Darśana: Right faith in Jīva-Ajīva distinction.
- Samyak Jñāna: Right knowledge of reality via Anekāntavāda.
- Samyak Chāritra: Right conduct through Mahāvratas (5 vows).
- Karma Mechanics:
IV. Soteriological Evolution: Key Shifts
Era/Text | Vedism | Upaniṣadic | Classical | Śramaṇa Traditions |
---|---|---|---|---|
Ultimate Goal | Pitṛloka | Mokṣa | Mokṣa/Bhakti | Nirvāṇa/Kevala Jñāna |
Mechanism | Ritual sacrifice | Self-knowledge | Multi-path (yogas) | Ethics + meditation |
Agent | Priests (hotṛ) | Seeker (muni) | Devotee (bhakta) | Ascetic (śramaṇa) |
Afterlife | Linear heaven | Cyclic rebirth | Liberation | Escape from rebirth |
V. Comparative Analysis
Concept | Hinduism | Buddhism | Jainism |
---|---|---|---|
Final Goal | Mokṣa (union with Brahman) | Nirvāṇa (extinction of craving) | Kaivalya (soul’s omniscient state) |
Path Structure | 4 Yogas (jñāna/bhakti/karma/rāja) | Noble Eightfold Path | [[Three Jewels (Jainism) |
Role of Deity | Central (Ishvara) in Bhakti | Buddha as guide, not savior | Tīrthaṅkara as exemplar |
Karma’s Nature | Ethical-ritual residue | Psychological (cetanā-based) | Physical particles (pudgala) |
Means to Goal | Grace (prasāda) + self-effort | Self-effort (vīrya) | Extreme asceticism (tapas) |
After-Death State | Satyaloka (Vedānta) or eternal service | Unconditioned state (no description) | Siddhaloka (pure soul realm) |
VII. Key Backlinks
- Mokṣa vs. Nirvāṇa: Hindu unification vs. Buddhist cessation.
- Karma mechanics: Contrasting Hindu ethical, Buddhist psychological, and Jain physical models.
- Ātman debates: Eternal self (Hindu/Jain) vs. no-self (Buddhist Anattā).
- Ascetic practices: Jain Sallekhana vs. Hindu Sannyāsa vs. Buddhist monasticism.
Glossary:
- Avidyā: Ignorance binding soul (Hinduism/Buddhism).
- Bodhicitta: Mahāyāna vow to liberate all beings.
- Kaivalya: Isolation of pure soul (Jainism/Sāṃkhya).
- Prasāda: Divine grace in Bhakti traditions.
- Tapas: Austerity to burn karma (Jainism).
Comprehensive MOC: Ethics in Indian Philosophy
I. Foundational Concepts
-
- Hinduism: Cosmic/social duty (varṇa/āśrama-specific; Manusmṛti).
- Buddhism: Dhamma = universal moral law (vs. caste duties).
- Jainism: Right conduct (Samyak Chāritra) through vows.
-
- Ethical cause-effect: Intentional actions → future consequences.
- Contrast:
- Hindu: Ritual + ethical dimensions (Bhagavad Gītā 2.47).
- Buddhist: Psychological (Cetanā-based; Majjhima Nikāya 135).
- Jain: Physical particles binding soul (Pudgala).
-
Ahimsā (Non-violence)
- Jainism: Absolute (e.g., Sallekhana fasting).
- Buddhism: First precept (avoid harming sentient beings).
- Hinduism: Contextual (permitted for kṣatriya Svadharma).
-
Purusharthas (Human Goals)
II. Hindu Ethical Systems
-
Vedic Ethics (1500–500 BCE)
-
Upaniṣadic Shift (800–500 BCE)
- Internalization: Truthfulness (Satya), self-control (Dama) > rituals.
- Karma Ethics: Rebirth based on moral actions (Bṛhadāraṇyaka Upaniṣad 3.2.13).
-
Classical Frameworks
Source Key Principles Emphasis Bhagavad Gītā Nishkāma Karma (selfless action) Duty without attachment Yoga Sūtras Yamas/Niyamas (e.g., ahimsā, satya) Ethical preconditions for liberation Dharmaśāstras Caste/gender duties (e.g., Stridharma) Social stability
III. Buddhist Ethics
-
Core Framework: Noble Eightfold Path
- Ethical Division:
- Right Speech (no lying/gossip).
- Right Action (no killing/stealing/sexual misconduct).
- Right Livelihood (non-harmful trades).
- Ethical Division:
-
Moral Codes
- Lay Precepts (Pañcaśīla):
- No killing.
- No stealing.
- No sexual misconduct.
- No false speech.
- No intoxicants.
- Monastic Rules (Vinaya Piṭaka): 227+ rules (e.g., celibacy, no money).
- Lay Precepts (Pañcaśīla):
-
Mahāyāna Expansion
- Bodhisattva Vow: Postpone nirvāṇa to save others.
- Upāya-Kauśalya: Skillful means (flexible ethics for compassion).
IV. Jain Ethics
-
- Samyak Darśana (faith in non-absolutism).
- Samyak Jñāna (knowledge of reality).
- Samyak Chāritra (conduct via vows).
-
Five Mahāvratas (Great Vows)
Vow Practice Radicality Ahimsā No harm to any life (avoid root vegetables) Most absolute among traditions Satya Truthfulness without exception Asteya Non-stealing Brahmacharya Celibacy (even in thought) Aparigraha Non-possession (monks own nothing) -
Applied Ethics
- Anekāntavāda: Multiple viewpoints → tolerance.
- Syādvāda: “Maybe” logic to avoid dogmatism.
V. Comparative Analysis
Issue | Hinduism | Buddhism | Jainism |
---|---|---|---|
Basis of Ethics | Dharma (caste-duty) | Dhamma (universal) | Vows (ahiṃsā-centered) |
Violence | Permitted for warriors (Arthaśāstra) | Only self-defense | Never justified |
Asceticism | Optional (Sannyāsa) | Monastic ideal | Mandatory for liberation |
Wealth Ethics | Artha as valid pursuit | Middle Way (avoid extremes) | Renunciation (Aparigraha) |
Gender Norms | Patriarchal (Stridharma) | Relatively egalitarian (sangha) | Female ascetics (Sadhvi) |
VI. Evolutionary Shifts
VII. Key Backlinks
- Dharma → Contrasts with Buddhist Dhamma (universal vs. caste-bound).
- Karma → Ethical intent (Buddhist) vs. ritual correctness (Vedic).
- Ahimsā spectrum: Jain absolutism → Hindu contextualism.
- Purusharthas vs. Buddhist Four Noble Truths: Worldly goals vs. renunciation.
Glossary:
- Svadharma: Personal duty (caste-specific).
- Yamas: Ethical restraints (e.g., non-violence, truthfulness).
- Upāya-Kauśalya: Skillful means (Mahāyāna).
- Sallekhana: Jain ritual fasting unto death.
- Kalyanamitra: Buddhist spiritual friend.
Comprehensive MOC: Scriptures of Indian Traditions
I. Hindu Scriptures
-
Śruti (Revealed)
Text Period Language Content Significance Ṛgveda Saṃhitā 1500–1200 BCE Vedic Sanskrit 1,028 hymns to deities (Indra, Agni) Oldest extant Indo-European text Sāmaveda 1200–1000 BCE Vedic Sanskrit Melodic chants (ṛc melodies) Liturgical manual for Udgātṛ priests Yajurveda 1100–900 BCE Vedic Sanskrit Ritual formulas (Black: prose; White: commentary) Manual for Adhvaryu priests Atharvaveda 1000–900 BCE Vedic Sanskrit Spells, healing, domestic rites Folk traditions + ritual magic Brāhmaṇas 900–700 BCE Vedic Sanskrit Ritual exegesis (e.g., Śatapatha Brāhmaṇa) Details symbolic meaning of yajña Āraṇyakas 700–600 BCE Vedic Sanskrit ”Forest treatises” (ritual internalization) Transition to Upaniṣads Upaniṣads 800–500 BCE Vedic Sanskrit Philosophical dialogues (e.g., Bṛhadāraṇyaka, Chāndogya) Foundation for Vedānta -
Smṛti (Remembered)
- Itihāsa (Epics):
- Mahābhārata (400 BCE–400 CE): 100,000 verses; includes Bhagavad Gītā (soteriology of yoga paths).
- Rāmāyaṇa (500 BCE–200 CE): 24,000 verses; life of Rāma (ideal dharma).
- Purāṇas (300–1200 CE):
- 18 Mahāpurāṇas (e.g., Viṣṇu Purāṇa – cosmogony; Śiva Purāṇa – Śaivism).
- 18 Upapurāṇas (regional traditions).
- Dharmaśāstras (200 BCE–300 CE):
- Manusmṛti – social laws (varṇa, gender duties).
- Yājñavalkyasmṛti – more liberal than Manu.
- Tantras (500–1300 CE):
- Śaiva/Śākta texts (e.g., Vijñāna Bhairava) – ritual, yoga, mantras.
- Itihāsa (Epics):
-
Darśanic Texts
School Key Text Author Content Vedānta Brahma Sūtras Bādarāyaṇa Systematizes Upaniṣadic teachings Sāṃkhya Sāṃkhya Kārikā Īśvarakṛṣṇa Dualism of puruṣa-prakṛti Yoga Yoga Sūtras Patañjali Aṣṭāṅga yoga (8-limbed path) Nyāya Nyāya Sūtras Gautama Logic, epistemology Vaiśeṣika Vaiśeṣika Sūtra Kaṇāda Atomism, 6 reality categories Mīmāṃsā Mīmāṃsā Sūtra Jaimini Vedic ritual hermeneutics
II. Buddhist Scriptures
-
Pāli Canon (Theravāda)
- Tipiṭaka (5th–1st c. BCE):
Basket Content Key Texts Vinaya Piṭaka Monastic rules (227 for monks, 311 for nuns) Pātimokkha Sutta Piṭaka Discourses of Buddha Dhammapada, Majjhima Nikāya Abhidhamma Piṭaka Philosophical analysis Dhammasaṅgaṇī
- Tipiṭaka (5th–1st c. BCE):
-
Mahāyāna Sūtras (1st c. BCE–5th c. CE)
Text Tradition Key Doctrine Prajñāpāramitā Sūtras Wisdom focus Śūnyatā (emptiness) Lotus Sūtra Universalist Ekayāna (one vehicle to Buddhahood) Heart Sūtra Concise wisdom ”Form is emptiness” Pure Land Sūtras Devotional Faith in Amitābha Buddha → rebirth in Sukhāvatī Avataṃsaka Sūtra Huayan/Kegon Interpenetration of all phenomena -
Tantric/Vajrayāna Texts (7th–12th c. CE)
- Guhyasamāja Tantra: Deity yoga, mandala practices.
- Hevajra Tantra: Yoginī cults, subtle body energy.
- Tibetan Book of the Dead (Bardo Thödol): Death/rebirth process.
III. Jain Scriptures
-
Śvetāmbara Canon
- Āgamas (c. 300 BCE–5th c. CE):
Category Key Texts Content Aṅga (Limbs) Ācārāṅga (conduct), Sūtrakṛtāṅga Monastic rules, refutation of heresies Upāṅga Prajñāpanā Sūtra Cosmology, karma theory Cheda Sūtras Niśītha Sūtra Expiation for monastic faults Mūla Sūtras Uttarādhyayana Sūtra Dialogues on liberation
- Āgamas (c. 300 BCE–5th c. CE):
-
Digambara Texts
- Ṣaṭkhaṇḍāgama: Karma theory (6 sections).
- Kasāyaprābhṛta: Passions and their destruction.
- Anuyogas: Exegetical works (e.g., Mahāpurāṇa by Jinasena).
-
Commentarial Literature
- Tattvārtha Sūtra (Umasvati): Unified epistemology/metaphysics.
- Ācārāṅga Bhāṣya (Śīlāṅka): Commentary on conduct.
IV. Comparative Analysis
Feature | Hinduism | Buddhism | Jainism |
---|---|---|---|
Revelation | Śruti (eternal sound) | Buddha’s enlightenment (historical) | Tīrthaṅkara teachings (divine) |
Language | Sanskrit (Vedic/Classical) | Pāli (Theravāda), Sanskrit (Mahāyāna) | Ardhamāgadhī (Śvetāmbara) |
Canon Structure | Śruti + Smṛti + Sectarian texts | Tripiṭaka + Mahāyāna Sūtras | Āgamas + Anuyogas |
Metaphysical Focus | Brahman-ātman, dharma | Anattā, śūnyatā | Anekāntavāda, jīva-ajīva |
Transmission | Oral (Vedas) → written (Purāṇas) | Oral → written (1st c. BCE) | Oral → written (5th c. CE) |
V. Key Historical Developments
-
Oral to Written
- Vedas: Memorized for millennia (śākhās = branches).
- Buddhist Councils:
- 1st (483 BCE): Sutta recitation.
- 4th (1st c. BCE): Pāli Canon written in Sri Lanka.
- Jain Schism (c. 300 BCE): Śvetāmbaras (written canon) vs. Digambaras (rejected canon).
-
Sectarian Expansion:
- Hindu: Purāṇas promote Vaiṣṇavism/Śaivism (e.g., Bhāgavata Purāṇa for Kṛṣṇa bhakti).
- Buddhist: Mahāyāna sūtras claim higher authenticity (Buddhavacana).
-
Commentarial Traditions:
- Hindu: Śaṅkara’s Brahmasūtra Bhāṣya (Advaita).
- Buddhist: Nāgārjuna’s Mūlamadhyamakakārikā (Madhyamaka).
- Jain: Haribhadra’s Ṣaḍdarśanasamuccaya (comparative philosophy).
VI. Lost/Contested Texts
- Hindu:
- Bṛhadāraṇyaka Upaniṣad references lost Vedic schools (e.g., Kāṇva recension).
- Buddhist:
- Early Mahāyāna sūtras (e.g., Tathāgataguhya Sūtra) preserved only in Tibetan/Chinese.
- Jain:
- Digambara rejection of Śvetāmbara Āgamas → independent texts.
VII. Scriptural Authority Debates
Tradition | Orthodoxy Criteria | Reformist Critiques |
---|---|---|
Hindu | Śruti infallibility; Vedic ritual continuity | Buddhism/Jainism: Reject Vedic authority |
Buddhist | ”Thus have I heard” (evam mayā śrutam) | Theravāda: Rejects Mahāyāna as later invention |
Jain | Tīrthaṅkara authenticity | Digambara: Śvetāmbara canon corrupted |
Key Backlinks:
- Śruti vs. Smṛti: Hindu revelation hierarchy.
- Buddhavacana: Buddhist “word of Buddha” debates.
- Āgama (Jainism): Jain canonical authority.
- Vedāṅgas: Auxiliary Vedic sciences (phonetics, astronomy).
Comprehensive MOC: Vaiṣṇavism
I. Theological Foundations
-
Viṣṇu as Supreme
- Para Brahman: Ultimate reality beyond form (contrasts with Śaiva non-dualism).
- Antaryāmī: Immanent indweller in all beings.
- Vyūha Doctrine: Emanations (Vāsudeva, Saṅkarṣaṇa, Pradyumna, Aniruddha).
-
Avatāra Theory
- Daśāvatāra (10 incarnations):
Avatāra Role Text Reference Rāma Dharma exemplar Rāmāyaṇa Kṛṣṇa Divine lover/philosopher Bhagavad Gītā, Bhāgavata Purāṇa Varāha Cosmic boar (rescues earth) Varāha Purāṇa Narasimha Man-lion (protects Prahlāda) Bhāgavata Purāṇa Canto 7 - Puruṣottama: “Supreme Person” beyond emanations (Bhagavad Gītā 15.18).
- Daśāvatāra (10 incarnations):
-
Cosmology
- Vaikuṇṭha: Eternal abode beyond material universes.
- Kāraṇodakaśāyī Viṣṇu: Viṣṇu reclining on causal ocean (creates universes).
II. Subtraditions & Schools
-
Śrīvaiṣṇavism (South India)
- Theology: Viṣiṣṭādvaita (qualified non-dualism) by Rāmānuja.
- Śrī (Lakṣmī): Mediatrix of grace (divine consort).
- Subschools:
- Vaḍagalai (Northern): Monkey-way (self-effort + grace; Vedānta Deśika).
- Teṉkalai (Southern): Cat-way (sole reliance on grace; Pillai Lokācārya).
- Practice: Prapatti (surrender), temple-centric worship.
-
Gauḍīya Vaiṣṇavism (Bengal)
- Founder: Caitanya Mahāprabhu (Kṛṣṇa as supreme form).
- Theology: Acintya Bhedābheda (inconceivable oneness/difference).
- Rādhā-Kṛṣṇa: Divine couple (highest expression of love).
- Practice: Saṅkīrtana (ecstatic chanting), Rāgānugā Bhakti (spontaneous devotion).
-
- Founder: Madhvācārya (Dvaita Vedānta – strict dualism).
- Tāratamya: Hierarchical reality (Viṣṇu > Lakṣmī > souls > matter).
- Texts: Sarvamūla Grantha (Madhva’s commentaries).
-
- Śuddhādvaita (pure non-dualism) by Vallabha.
- Puṣṭi Mārga: Path of grace (emphasizes Kṛṣṇa’s childhood).
- Practice: Sevā (deity service), Aṣṭayāma (8 daily services).
-
- Dvaitādvaita (duality-nonduality) by Nimbārka.
- Yugala Upāsana: Worship of Rādhā-Kṛṣṇa as divine pair.
-
Ekasarana Dharma (Assam)
- Founder: Śaṅkaradeva (simplified devotion).
- Texts: Kīrtana Ghosā (vernacular hymns).
III. Metaphysics & Soteriology
-
Jīva (Soul)
- Eternal servant of Viṣṇu (Śeṣa-Śeṣī Bhāva).
- Three States:
-
Liberation Pathways
IV. Sacred Texts
Category | Key Texts | Tradition |
---|---|---|
Vedic | Vaiṣṇava Upaniṣads (e.g., Nārāyaṇa) | All |
Itihāsa | Mahābhārata (incl. Gītā), Rāmāyaṇa | Pan-Vaiṣṇava |
Purāṇic | Viṣṇu Purāṇa, Bhāgavata Purāṇa | Śrīvaiṣṇava/Gauḍīya |
Tantric | Pāñcarātra Āgamas | Śrīvaiṣṇava |
Poetic | Gītagovinda (Jayadeva) | Gauḍīya/Assamese |
Philosophical | Śrī Bhāṣya (Rāmānuja) | Śrīvaiṣṇava |
V. Rituals & Practices
-
Temple Worship
- Arcana: Deity service (Mūrti as embodied God).
- Utsava: Festivals (e.g., Ratha Yātrā, Janmāṣṭamī).
-
Personal Devotion
- Nāma Japa: Repetition of divine names (e.g., “Hare Kṛṣṇa”).
- Bhāgavata Saptāha: 7-day recitation of Bhāgavata Purāṇa.
-
Initiation
- Dīkṣā: Formal entry via guru (receives Mantra).
- Vaiṣṇava Tilaka: Forehead marking (U/V shape).
VI. Key Figures
Philosopher | Tradition | Contribution |
---|---|---|
Rāmānuja | Śrīvaiṣṇavism | Viśiṣṭādvaita; Śrī Bhāṣya commentary |
Madhvācārya | Brahma Sampradāya | Dvaita Vedānta; refuted Māyāvāda |
Vallabha | Rudra Sampradāya | Puṣṭi Mārga; Śuddhādvaita |
Caitanya | Gauḍīya | Kṛṣṇa-bhakti ecstasy; Aṣṭakālīya Līlā |
Vedānta Deśika | Vaḍagalai | Defense of Viśiṣṭādvaita; 120+ works |
VII. Subtradition-Specific Practices
-
Śrīvaiṣṇava:
- Divya Prabandha: Tamil hymns by Āḻvārs (equal to Vedas).
- Maṇḍala Pūjā: Complex temple rituals (Pāñcarātra Āgamas).
-
Gauḍīya:
- Guru-paramparā: Disciplic succession (Brahmā-Madhva-Caitanya).
- Manjari Svarūpa: Self-identification as Rādhā’s handmaiden.
-
Puṣṭi Mārga:
- Bāla-Kṛṣṇa Focus: Childhood pastimes (makhan chor).
- Havelī Saṅgīta: Devotional music in temples.
VIII. Interactions with Other Traditions
-
With Śaivism:
- Debates on supremacy (Viṣṇu vs. Śiva) in Skanda Purāṇa.
- Syncretism: Harihara icon (half-Viṣṇu, half-Śiva).
-
With Buddhism:
- Avalokiteśvara (Buddhist) → Padmanābha form of Viṣṇu.
-
With Islam:
- Sants (Kabīr, Nānak) blended bhakti with Sufi themes.
IX. Modern Expressions
-
Global Movements:
- ISKCON (1966): Gauḍīya-based; global Kṛṣṇa consciousness.
- Swaminarayan: Gujarati Vaiṣṇavism (Akṣara-Puruṣottama Darsana).
-
Reform Debates:
- Caste in temples (e.g., Sabrimala controversy).
- Gender roles: Female gurus in ISKCON.
Key Backlinks:
- Avatāra → Links to Rāma, Kṛṣṇa, Bhāgavata Purāṇa
- Viśiṣṭādvaita vs. Dvaita: Śrīvaiṣṇava-Brahma Sampradāya contrasts
- Pāñcarātra → Temple rituals, Vyūha doctrine
- Rāsa Līlā → Gauḍīya theology of divine play
- Śaraṇāgati → Śrīvaiṣṇava surrender vs. Gauḍīya Rāgānugā
Comprehensive MOC: Śaivism
I. Theological Foundations
-
Śiva as Supreme
- Parameśvara: Supreme being beyond Brahman (contrasts with Vaiṣṇava Viṣṇu as sustainer) .
- Pañchakṛtya: Five cosmic functions—creation (sṛṣṭi), preservation (sthiti), dissolution (saṃhāra), concealment (tirobhāva), grace (anugraha) .
- Liṅga-Yoni: Aniconic symbol of transcendent-immanent reality; union of consciousness (Śiva) and energy (Śakti) .
-
Forms of Śiva
Form Significance Textual Reference Natarāja Cosmic dancer (destroys ignorance) Chidambaram Stotra Rudra Vedic “Howler” (fierce aspect) Ṛgveda 2.33 Dakṣiṇāmūrti Silent teacher of yoga Śiva Purāṇa Ardhanārīśvara Androgynous unity of Śiva-Śakti Kūrma Purāṇa -
Cosmology
- Mount Kailāsa: Abode of Śiva; axis of universe .
- Bhairava: Fierce aspect governing time (kāla) and dissolution .
II. Subtraditions & Schools
-
Śaiva Siddhānta (Tamil Nadu/Sri Lanka)
- Theology: Dualistic realism—Pati (Lord), Paśu (soul), Pāśa (bonds) .
- Liberation: Grace (arul) through Caryā-Kriyā-Yoga-Jñāna (4-fold path) .
- Subschools:
- Meykaṇḍa Sampradāya: Pluralistic souls (Meykaṇḍar, 13th c.) .
- Śrīkaṇṭha Advaita: Monistic-leaning (Śrīkaṇṭha’s Brahma Sūtra Bhāṣya) .
-
Kashmiri Śaivism (Trika)
- Founders: Vasugupta (9th c.), Abhinavagupta (10th c.) .
- Theology: Pratyabhijñā (recognition of Self as Śiva); consciousness (cit) vibrates as universe (spanda) .
- Texts: Śiva Sūtras, Tantrāloka.
-
Vīraśaivism (Karnataka)
- Founder: Basava (12th c.); rejects caste, Vedic ritual .
- Practice: Wearing iṣṭaliṅga (personal Śiva emblem); equality of women .
-
Pāśupata (Oldest ascetic order)
- Rituals: Deliberate transgression (avadhūta) to overcome ego .
- Goal: Rudraśāyujya (union with Rudra) .
-
Nātha (Hatha Yoga lineage)
- Key Figures: Matsyendranāth, Gorakṣanāth .
- Practice: Kuṇḍalinī Yoga to awaken Śakti .
-
Aghora (Transgressive Tantra)
- Practices: Cremation-ground rituals; transcendence of duality .
III. Metaphysics & Soteriology
-
Śakti (Divine Power)
-
Nature of Soul
- Śaiva Siddhānta: Eternal but distinct souls (aṇu) .
- Kashmiri Śaivism: No separate soul; only Śiva’s consciousness .
-
Liberation Pathways
Path Mechanism Tradition Bhakti Mārga Devotion (e.g., Nayanar poets) Tamil Śaivism Yoga Mārga Kuṇḍalinī ascent through cakras Nātha/Kashmiri Jñāna Mārga Self-recognition (pratyabhijñā) Kashmiri Śaivism Kriyā Mārga Ritual (āgamic pūjā) Siddhānta
IV. Sacred Texts
Category | Key Texts | Tradition |
---|---|---|
Vedic | Śvetāśvatara Upaniṣad (monistic Śiva) | Pan-Śaiva |
Āgamas | 28 Śaivāgamas (e.g., Kāmika, Mṛgendra) | Siddhānta/Tantra |
Tantric | Vijñāna Bhairava (yogic methods) | Kashmiri |
Poetic | Tirumurai (Tamil hymns by Nayanars) | Siddhānta |
Philosophical | Śiva Sūtras (Kashmiri metaphysics) | Trika |
V. Rituals & Practices
-
Temple Worship
- Liṅgābhiṣeka: Ritual bathing of liṅga with milk/water .
- Mahāśivarātri: All-night fasting/meditation .
-
Asceticism
-
Tantric Rites
- Yoginī Cult: Worship of 64 goddesses; cremation-ground rituals .
- Nyāsa: Mantra-infusion of the body .
VI. Key Figures
Philosopher | Tradition | Contribution |
---|---|---|
Abhinavagupta | Kashmiri Śaivism | Synthesized Trika in Tantrāloka |
Meykaṇḍar | Śaiva Siddhānta | Śivajñānabodham (dualist theology) |
Basava | Vīraśaivism | Rejected caste; vacanas (poems) |
Gorakṣanāth | Nātha | Systematized Haṭha Yoga |
VII. Subtradition-Specific Practices
-
Śaiva Siddhānta:
- Tiruvarutpa: “Divine grace songs” of Nayanars .
- Caryā Pāda: Ritual service in temples .
-
Kashmiri Śaivism:
- Śāmbhavopāya: Non-dual meditation beyond mantra .
- Spanda Kārikā: Contemplation of divine vibration .
-
Vīraśaivism:
VIII. Interactions with Other Traditions
-
With Vaiṣṇavism:
- Debates on supremacy (e.g., Śiva vs. Viṣṇu in Skanda Purāṇa) .
- Syncretism: Harihara icons (half-Śiva/half-Viṣṇu) .
-
With Buddhism:
- Shared tantric practices (e.g., mahāmudrā in Vajrayāna) .
- Śiva as Maheśvara in Buddhist tantras .
-
With Śāktism:
- Overlap in goddess worship; Śakti as Śiva’s active aspect .
IX. Modern Expressions
-
Global Movements:
- Himalayan Academy: Diaspora Śaiva Siddhānta Church .
- Kaṭhpīā Ascetics: Nāgā sādhus at Kumbh Melā .
-
Contemporary Issues:
- Temple entry rights (e.g., Sabarimala controversy) .
- Eco-Śaivism: Reverence for nature as Śiva’s manifestation .
Key Backlinks:
Contrasts with Vaiṣṇavism
Aspect | Śaivism | Vaiṣṇavism |
---|---|---|
Ultimate Reality | Śiva as destroyer-regenerator | Viṣṇu as preserver |
Liberation Goal | Kaivalya (ontological freedom) | Sāyujya (eternal service) |
Primary Path | Yoga/asceticism | Bhakti/devotion |
Cosmology | Cyclic dissolution (pralaya) | Sustained order (dharma) |
Social Structure | Accepts ascetic outliers | Caste-integrated (varṇāśrama) |
Comprehensive MOC: Śāktism
I. Theological Foundations
-
Devī as Supreme
- Ādi Parāśakti: Ultimate reality beyond form; source of Trinity (Brahmā-Viṣṇu-Śiva) .
- Prakṛti: Cosmic energy manifesting as material world (contrasts with Vaiṣṇava Puruṣa-centricity) .
- Mahāvidyās: 10 Wisdom-Goddess forms (e.g., Kālī, Tārā, Tripurasundarī) .
-
Cosmic Functions
- Sṛṣṭi (Creation): Lalitā Tripurasundarī
- Sthiti (Preservation): Pārvatī
- Saṃhāra (Destruction): Kālī/Chinnamastā
- Tirobhāva (Concealment): Bagalāmukhī
- Anugraha (Grace): Bhuvaneśvarī
-
Cosmology
- Śrī Yantra: Geometric diagram of cosmic creation .
- Kāmakalā: Triadic symbol of divine desire (Icchā-Jñāna-Kriyā Śaktis) .
II. Subtraditions & Schools
-
Śrī Vidyā (South India/Kashmir)
- Deity Focus: Tripurasundarī (Lalitā) as benevolent queen .
- Practice: Śrī Cakra worship; Navāvaraṇa Pūjā (9-circuit ritual) .
- Texts: Vāmakeśvara Tantra, Saundarya Lahari .
-
Kālī Kula (Bengal/Assam)
- Deity Focus: Kālī as transformative darkness .
- Practice: Śava Sādhanā (cremation-ground rituals); animal sacrifice .
- Texts: Kālī Tantra, Mahānirvāṇa Tantra .
-
Saura-Śākta Syncretism (Odisha)
- Sūrya-Chāyā: Sun Goddess worship (Konark Temple) .
- Texts: Saura Tantra .
-
Tibetan Vajrayāna Integration
III. Metaphysics & Soteriology
-
- Divine energy as immanent reality; Śiva as static consciousness (Cit) .
- Contrast with Śaivism: Śakti > Śiva (vs. Śaiva equality) .
-
Liberation Pathways
Path Mechanism Tradition Kaula Mārga Transgressive rituals (5 Ms: madya, māṃsa, matsya, mudrā, maithuna) Kālī Kula Samayā Internalized worship (mental rituals) Śrī Vidyā Yoginī Cult Goddess-circle practices (64 Yoginīs) Medieval Tantra -
Kuṇḍalinī Dynamics
- Awakening serpent power through cakras → union with Śiva in Sahasrāra .
IV. Sacred Texts
Category | Key Texts | Tradition |
---|---|---|
Vedic Roots | Devī Sūkta (Ṛgveda 10.125) | Pan-Śākta |
Purāṇic | Devī Bhāgavata Purāṇa, Kālikā Purāṇa | Kālī Kula |
Tantric | Tantrarāja Tantra, Yoginī Tantra | Śrī Vidyā/Kālī Kula |
Poetic | Devī Māhātmya (700 verses) | Core liturgical text |
V. Rituals & Practices
-
Temple Worship
- Navarātri: 9-night festival (Durgā’s victory over Mahiṣāsura) .
- Kumārī Pūjā: Worship of prepubescent girls as Devī incarnate .
-
Tantric Rites
- Nyāsa: Mantra-placement on body parts .
- Yantra Pūjā: Geometric diagram worship (e.g., Śrī Cakra) .
-
Asceticism
- Śākta Sannyāsinīs: Female renunciates (e.g., Mā Ānandamayī) .
VI. Key Figures
Philosopher | Tradition | Contribution |
---|---|---|
Bhāskararāya | Śrī Vidyā | Varivasyā-Rahasya (commentary) |
Rāmprasād Sen | Kālī Kula | Bengali devotional songs (śyāmā saṅgīt) |
Abhirāmī Bhattar | Tamil Śākta | Abhirāmī Antāti (poems) |
Lakṣmīṅkarā | Yoginī Cult | Tantric female master (9th c.) |
VII. Subtradition-Specific Practices
-
Śrī Vidyā:
- Śodaśī: Ritual worship of Tripurasundarī as 16-year-old .
- Parāparā Vidyā: Secret mantras (e.g., 15-syllable Śrī Vidyā) .
-
Kālī Kula:
- Śmaśāna Sādhanā: Midnight meditation in cremation grounds .
- Bali: Ritual offering (historically animal, now symbolic) .
-
Bengal Vaiṣṇava-Śākta Syncretism:
- Rādhā-Kālī: Fusion of Kṛṣṇa devotion with Kālī’s fierceness .
VIII. Interactions with Other Traditions
-
With Śaivism:
- Ardhanārīśvara: Theological unity debates .
- Kashmiri Trika: Shared non-dual metaphysics (pratyabhijñā) .
-
With Buddhism:
- Tārā ↔ Kurukullā: Cross-traditional goddess forms .
- Chinnamastā in both Hindu/Buddhist Tantra .
-
With Folk Traditions:
- Grāmadevatā: Village goddesses (e.g., Mariamman) absorbed as Devī forms .
IX. Modern Expressions
-
Global Movements:
- Shree Maa (Kālī ashram in California) .
- Art of Living: Śrī Vidyā elements in advanced courses .
-
Feminist Reinterpretations:
- Devī as symbol of female empowerment .
- Critique of patriarchal ritual elements (e.g., animal sacrifice) .
Key Backlinks:
- Mahāvidyās → Links to Kālī, Tārā, Chinnamastā
- Śrī Cakra vs. Liṅga: Geometric vs. aniconic worship
- Kaula Mārga → Transgressive practices debated in orthodox Hinduism
- Devī Māhātmya → Core narrative of Durgā’s cosmic victory
Contrasts with Śaivism/Vaiṣṇavism
Aspect | Śāktism | Śaivism | Vaiṣṇavism |
---|---|---|---|
Ultimate Reality | Devī as active principle (Prakṛti) | Śiva as consciousness (Puruṣa) | Viṣṇu as sustainer (Puruṣa) |
Liberation | Union with Śakti (Śāyujya) | Śiva-identity (Kaivalya) | Eternal service (Dāsya) |
Primary Symbol | Yantra/Maṇḍala | Liṅga | Śālagrāma/Mūrti |
Ritual Focus | Menstrual/fertility symbolism | Ascetic renunciation | Devotional surrender (Prapatti) |
Guru Lineage | Kālīkula vs. Śrīkula | Nāth Siddhas | Rāmānuja/Madhva lineages |
Comprehensive MOC: Smārtism
I. Theological Foundations
-
- Saguna Brahman-Nirguna Brahman: Worship of personal deities (Viṣṇu, Śiva, Devī, Gaṇeśa, Sūrya) as manifestations of formless Absolute.
- Pañcāyatana Pūjā: Ritual worship of five deities in a circle (symbolizing unity of Brahman).
- Contrast with sectarian traditions: Rejects exclusive deity allegiance (vs. Vaiṣṇavism/Śaivism).
-
Advaita Vedānta Core
- Ātman-Brahman Unity: Liberation through realizing non-duality (Jñāna Yoga).
- Māyā: World as relative reality (vivarta vāda).
- Contrast with Dvaita: Rejects eternal soul-God distinction.
-
Scriptural Authority
- Triple Canon (Prasthānatrayī):
- Upaniṣads (philosophical basis)
- Brahma Sūtras (systematic framework)
- Bhagavad Gītā (practical ethics)
- Smṛti Supremacy: Dharmaśāstras (e.g., Manusmṛti) as social guide.
- Triple Canon (Prasthānatrayī):
II. Historical Development
-
Ādi Śaṅkara (788–820 CE)
- Established four Maṭhas (monasteries):
- Revival Strategy:
- Debated Buddhist/Mīmāṃsā scholars
- Composed devotional hymns (e.g., Śivanandalaharī)
-
Post-Śaṅkara Traditions
- Vācaspati Miśra (9th c.): Harmonized Advaita with Nyāya.
- Vidyāraṇya (14th c.): Authored Pañcadaśī; guided Vijayanagara Empire.
III. Rituals & Practices
-
- Daily Vedic twilight ritual:
- Ācamana (purification)
- Prāṇāyāma (breath control)
- Gāyatrī Mantra recitation (Ṛgveda 3.62.10)
- Daily Vedic twilight ritual:
-
Pañcāyatana Pūjā Mechanics
-
Lifecycle Rites (Saṃskāra)
IV. Philosophical Contributions
-
- Pedagogical method: Superimposition (adhyāropa) and negation (apavāda) of attributes on Brahman.
-
Dharma Framework
- Fourfold Pursuits (Puruṣārtha):
- Varṇāśrama Integration:
- Affirms caste duties while teaching ultimate non-duality.
V. Key Texts & Commentaries
Text | Author | Significance |
---|---|---|
Upadeśasāhasrī | Ādi Śaṅkara | Pedagogical manual for non-duality |
Vivekachūḍāmaṇi | Attributed | ”Crest-jewel of discernment” (jñāna yoga) |
Pañcadaśī | Vidyāraṇya | 15-chapter Advaita treatise |
Śaṅkaravijaya | Multiple | Hagiographies of Śaṅkara |
VI. Monastic Orders
-
- Ten renunciate lineages:
Order Suffix Symbolic Meaning Araṇya -aranya Forest-dweller Bhāratī -bhāratī Knowledge bearer Giri -giri Mountain ascetic Parvata -parvata Mountain peak Sāgara -sāgara Oceanic consciousness
- Ten renunciate lineages:
-
Initiation (Sannyāsa Dīkṣā)
- Yati (monk) vows: Non-violence, poverty, chastity, truthfulness.
VII. Regional Expressions
-
- Integration of Āḻvār hymns (e.g., selective adoption in Cidambaram).
-
- Gaṇeśa focus (e.g., Aṣṭavināyaka pilgrimage).
VIII. Modern Adaptations
-
Global Movements
- Ramakrishna Mission: Vivekananda’s practical Vedānta.
- Chinmaya Mission: Scriptural education for diaspora.
-
Contemporary Debates
- Caste: Orthodoxy vs. reform (e.g., Sabarimala entry controversy).
- Gender: Female monasticism (e.g., Pravrajika Gayatriprana).
Key Backlinks:
- Pañcāyatana Pūjā → Contrasts with sectarian mūrti worship
- Dashanami Sampradāya → Monastic networks preserving Advaita
- Māyā vs. Śakti: Smārta illusion-theory vs. Śākta power-theology
- Śṛṅgeri Maṭha → Hub of Smārta orthodoxy
Contrasts with Sectarian Traditions
Aspect | Smārtism | Vaiṣṇavism | Śāktism |
---|---|---|---|
Ultimate Reality | Nirguṇa Brahman (with saguṇa worship) | Personal Viṣṇu/Kṛṣṇa | Devī as Prakṛti |
Liberation Path | Jñāna Yoga (knowledge) | Bhakti Yoga (devotion) | Tantric initiation |
Social Structure | Strict varṇāśrama | Varies (e.g., caste critique) | Often anti-caste |
Ritual Focus | Vedic fire rites + pañcāyatana | Temple pūjā/seva | Yantra/tantra rituals |
Comprehensive MOC: Buddhism
I. Historical Foundations
-
Life of Siddhārtha Gautama (563–483 BCE)
- Key Events:
- Four Sights (old age, sickness, death, ascetic) → Renunciation
- Bodhi Tree Enlightenment (Nirvāṇa at 35)
- First Sermon at Deer Park (Dharmacakrapravartana Sūtra)
- Parinirvāṇa: Death at Kuśinagara (age 80)
- Key Events:
-
Early Buddhist Councils
Council Year Location Key Outcome 1st 483 BCE Rājagṛha Vinaya Piṭaka recited; Sutta collection 2nd 383 BCE Vaiśālī Schism: Sthavira vs. Mahāsāṃghika 3rd 250 BCE Pāṭaliputra Abhidhamma Piṭaka finalized; missions sent 4th 1st c. CE Kashmir Mahāyāna sūtras written down -
Imperial Patronage
II. Core Doctrines (Dharma)
-
Four Noble Truths (Cattāri Ariyasaccāni)
- Dukkha: Suffering is universal
- Samudaya: Craving (Taṇhā) as cause
- Nirodha: Cessation is possible
- Magga: Eightfold Path as solution
-
Pratītyasamutpāda (Dependent Origination)
- 12 Links: Ignorance → Volitional formations → Consciousness → … → Suffering
- Key Implication: No creator god; self as process (vs. Vaiṣṇava Ishvara)
III. Major Schools
-
Theravāda (Path of Elders)
- Geography: Sri Lanka, SE Asia
- Goal: Arhat (self-liberated being)
- Texts: Pāli Canon (only complete early canon)
- Practice: Vipassanā (insight meditation), monastic discipline
-
Mahāyāna (Great Vehicle)
- Innovations:
- Bodhisattva Ideal: Postpone nirvāṇa to save others
- Śūnyatā: Emptiness of inherent existence (Nāgārjuna)
- Tathāgatagarbha: Buddha-nature in all beings
- Subschools:
School Key Text Focus Madhyamaka Mūlamadhyamakakārikā Dialectical negation Yogācāra Saṃdhinirmocana Sūtra Mind-only (cittamātra) Pure Land Sukhāvatīvyūha Sūtra Faith in Amitābha
- Innovations:
-
Vajrayāna (Diamond Vehicle)
- Geography: Tibet, Mongolia, Japan (Shingon)
- Methods:
- Tantra Classes:
- Kriyā (action), Caryā (conduct), Yoga (union), Anuttarayoga (highest)
IV. Scriptures
-
Tripiṭaka (Pāli Canon)
Basket Content Key Texts Vinaya Piṭaka Monastic rules Pātimokkha Sutta Piṭaka Discourses Dhammapada, Majjhima Nikāya Abhidhamma Piṭaka Philosophical psychology Dhammasaṅgaṇī -
Mahāyāna Sūtras
- Prajñāpāramitā: Heart Sūtra, Diamond Sūtra (emptiness)
- Buddhāvataṃsaka: Avataṃsaka Sūtra (interdependence)
- Tathāgatagarbha: Tathāgatagarbha Sūtra (Buddha-nature)
-
Vajrayāna Tantras
- Guhyasamāja Tantra: Seminal yoga tantra
- Kālacakra Tantra: Time-wheel cosmology
V. Practices & Institutions
-
Monastic Life
-
Lay Practices
VI. Buddhist-Hindu Interactions
-
Shared Concepts
- Karma/Saṃsāra: Modified from Upaniṣadic ideas
- Meditation Techniques: Similar to Yoga/Rāja Yoga
-
Divergences
Concept Buddhism Hinduism Ultimate Reality Śūnyatā (emptiness) Brahman/Ātman (essence) Liberation Nirvāṇa (cessation) Mokṣa (union) Deity Worship Buddha as teacher, not savior Ishvara as grace-giver Social Order Rejects caste Varṇa integral -
Syncretism
- Tantra: Shared ritual techiques (e.g., mantras)
- Avalokiteśvara-Śiva: Fused iconography in Nepal
VII. Modern Developments
-
Revival Movements
- Theravāda Revival: Ledi Sayadaw (Burma), Vipassanā global spread
- Engaged Buddhism: Thích Nhất Hạnh (social justice)
-
Western Adaptations
- Secular Buddhism: Mindfulness without rebirth doctrine
- Neo-Buddhism: Ambedkar’s Dalit conversion movement
-
Current Issues
- Buddhist Nationalism: Myanmar, Sri Lanka
- Gender: Revival of Bhikkhunī ordination
Key Backlinks:
- Anattā → Contrast with Hindu Ātman and Jain Jīva
- Bodhisattva vs. Arhat: Mahāyāna-Theravāda soteriological divide
- Pratītyasamutpāda vs. Ṛta: Buddhist interdependence vs. Vedic cosmic order
- Vajrayāna ↔ Śākta Tantra: Shared ritual grammar
Contrasts Summary
Issue | Theravāda | Mahāyāna | Vajrayāna | Hinduism |
---|---|---|---|---|
Ultimate Goal | Arhat (self-liberation) | Buddhahood (for all) | Rainbow Body | Mokṣa (union) |
Buddha Nature | Historical Buddha | Cosmic Buddha-nature | Buddha as Yidam deity | N/A |
Scriptures | Pāli Canon only | Mahāyāna Sūtras added | Tantras as highest | Vedas + sectarian texts |
Deity Role | Minimal | Celestial Buddhas (e.g., Amitābha) | Meditational deities | Ishvara as creator |
Comprehensive MOC: Jainism
I. Historical Foundations
-
Tīrthaṅkaras (Ford-Makers)
- 24 Liberated Teachers; final two are historically attested:
- Pārśvanātha (9th c. BCE): Taught Caujjāma (4 restraints)
- Mahāvīra (599–527 BCE): Added 5th restraint; compiled teachings
- Enlightenment Events:
- Mahāvīra’s Kevala Jñāna under Sāla tree (age 42)
- Final Nirvāṇa at Pāvāpur (age 72)
- 24 Liberated Teachers; final two are historically attested:
-
Schisms
- Great Schism (c. 300 BCE):
Branch Key Difference Geography Digambara Monastic nudity (Sky-Clad); no female liberation Karnataka, Maharashtra Śvetāmbara White-robed monks; women can achieve liberation Gujarat, Rajasthan - Subsects:
- Digambara: Terāpanthī (reformist), Bīsapanthī (orthodox)
- Śvetāmbara: Sthānakavāsī (no idols), Mūrtipūjaka (idol worship)
- Great Schism (c. 300 BCE):
-
Imperial Patronage
- Chandragupta Maurya: Became Digambara monk; migrated to Shravanabelagola
- King Khāravela (1st c. BCE): Kalinga ruler; patronized Jain caves (Udayagiri)
II. Core Doctrines
-
Metaphysics
- Anekāntavāda: Reality has infinite aspects (rejects dogmatism)
- Syādvāda: “Maybe-logic” (saptabhaṅgī – sevenfold predication)
- Dravya: 6 Eternal Substances:
- Anekāntavāda: Reality has infinite aspects (rejects dogmatism)
-
Ethics
- Five Mahāvratas (Great Vows):
- Ahimsā (non-violence) – Most absolute in world religions
- Satya (truthfulness)
- Asteya (non-stealing)
- Brahmacharya (chastity)
- Aparigraha (non-possession)
- Hierarchy of Life Forms:
- Sensed Beings: 1–5 senses (plants: 1; humans/animals: 5)
- Avoid harming higher-sensed beings strictly
- Five Mahāvratas (Great Vows):
-
Soteriology
- Karma Mechanism:
- Karma as sticky matter (Pudgala) binding soul → colors it (Leśyā)
- 14 Guṇasthāna: Stages of soul purification
- Liberation Path:
- Three Jewels: Right Faith (Samyak Darśana), Right Knowledge (Samyak Jñāna), Right Conduct (Samyak Chāritra)
- Goal: Siddhaloka – realm of perfected souls (no body, pure consciousness)
- Karma Mechanism:
III. Subtraditions & Practices
-
Asceticism
- Monastic Rules:
Digambara Śvetāmbara No clothing White robes Eat standing, once/day Eat seated, twice/day Carry peacock-feather broom Use mouth-mask (Muhapattī) - Sallekhanā: Ritual fast unto death (sanctioned when body fails)
- Monastic Rules:
-
Lay Practices
- Paryuṣaṇa: 8-day festival (forgiveness rituals; Micchāmi Dukkaḍaṃ)
- Samayika: 48-min meditation to embody monk-like state
- Temple Rituals:
- Abhiṣeka (Jina idol bathing)
- Caitya Paripāṭī (temple circumambulation)
-
Visual Culture
- Siddhacakra: Ritual diagram of liberation path
- Cosmic Diagrams: Loka (universe) paintings
IV. Scriptures
Tradition | Canon | Key Texts |
---|---|---|
Śvetāmbara | Āgamas (c. 500 CE) | - Ācārāṅga Sūtra (conduct) |
- Tattvārtha Sūtra (metaphysics; by Umāsvāti) | ||
- Kalpa Sūtra (biographies) | ||
Digambara | Anuyoga | - Ṣaṭkhaṇḍāgama (karma theory) |
- Dravyasaṃgraha (substances) | ||
- Samayasāra (soul essence; Kundakunda) |
V. Philosophical Contributions
-
- Parable of Blind Men & Elephant: Rejects single-truth claims
- Dialectical Method:
- Syāt (“maybe”): Reality described conditionally (e.g., “Syāt pot exists”)
-
Ethical Innovations
- Bioethics: Absolute Ahimsā → vegetarianism, no farming (Digambara)
- Economics: Aparigraha limits wealth accumulation
VI. Interactions with Other Traditions
-
With Hinduism:
- Shared: Karma/Saṃsāra, Ascetic ideals
- Divergence:
-
With Buddhism:
- Rejected: Buddhist Anattā (Jains affirm eternal soul)
- Shared: Monastic structure, Middle Way (vs. extreme asceticism)
VII. Modern Expressions
-
Reform Movements
- Terāpanthī: Anuvrat movement (small vows for laypeople)
- Vīrāśāiva Influence: Basava’s anti-caste stance adopted by Jains
-
Global Presence
-
Controversies
- Gender: Digambara exclusion of women from liberation
- Technology: Microorganism harm in digital devices (ethical debates)
Key Backlinks:
- Anekāntavāda → Contrasts with Hindu absolutism/Buddhist emptiness
- Sallekhanā vs. Hindu Sannyāsa: Ritual death vs. renunciation
- Jīva vs. Ātman: Plural souls vs. universal self
- Mahāvīra vs. Buddha: Contemporary reformers with divergent teachings
Contrasts Summary
Aspect | Jainism | Hinduism | Buddhism |
---|---|---|---|
Ultimate Reality | Eternal plural souls | Brahman/Ātman unity | No-self (Anattā) |
Liberation | Siddha (pure consciousness) | Mokṣa (union) | Nirvāṇa (cessation) |
Karma | Physical matter binding soul | Ethical residue | Mental intention (Cetanā) |
Asceticism | Extreme (e.g., nudity, plucking hair) | Moderate (Sannyāsa) | Middle Way |
Dietary Laws | Strict vegetarianism (+ no root vegetables) | Vegetarian optional | Varies by school |
Comprehensive MOC: Sikhism
I. Historical Foundations
-
Guru Period (1469–1708)
Guru Years Key Contribution Guru Nānak 1469–1539 Founded Sikhism; Ik Oaṅkār monotheism; opposed caste Guru Aṅgad 1539–1552 Standardized Gurmukhī script; formalized Laṅgar Guru Arjan 1581–1606 Compiled Ādi Granth; built Harmandir Sahib; martyred Guru Tegh Bahādur 1665–1675 Martyred defending Kashmiri Hindus Guru Gobind Singh 1675–1708 Founded Khalsa; declared Guru Granth Sahib eternal Guru -
Post-Guru Period
- Khalsa (1699): “Pure” warrior-saint order; Pañj Kakkār (5 Ks) mandated.
- Mughal Conflict: Martyrdom of Gurus 5 & 9; Banda Singh Bahādur’s rebellion (1710–1716).
- Sikh Empire (1799–1849): Maharaja Ranjit Singh unified Punjab; secular rule.
II. Theology & Metaphysics
-
Concept of God
-
Cosmogony
-
Human Condition
- Haumai: Ego as root suffering.
- Liberation: Jīvan Mukti (freedom while alive) through Nām Simran (remembrance of God).
- Contrast with Hinduism: No caste-based rebirth; rejects asceticism.
III. Scriptures
-
- Structure: 1,430 pages; 6 Gurus + 30 non-Sikh Bhagats (e.g., Kabir, Farid).
- Language: Sant Bhāṣā (mix of Punjabi, Braj, Persian).
- Theology: Rāg-based organization – devotional moods tied to musical scales.
-
Secondary Texts
- Dasam Granth: Guru Gobind Singh’s compositions (e.g., Jaap Sahib; controversial).
- Sarbloh Granth: Khalsa liturgy (veneration varies by sect).
IV. Practices & Rituals
-
Five Ks (Pañj Kakkār)
-
Core Observances
- Nitnem: Daily prayers (Japjī Sahib at dawn; Rehras at dusk).
- Gurdwara Protocol: Remove shoes; cover head; sit on floor (equality).
- Laṅgar: Communal vegetarian meal – all castes/diners eat together.
-
Lifecycle Rites
- Nām Karaṅ: Naming ceremony – random hymn from Guru Granth.
- Anand Kāraj: Wedding – circumambulating Guru Granth.
- Antim Saṃskār: Cremation; no ritual mourning.
V. Sects & Movements
-
Orthodox
- Khalsa: Dominant tradition; follows Sikh Rehat Maryada (code).
- Nirmalā: Scholarly order; Sanskritized theology.
-
Heterodox
-
Modern Reformists
- Singh Sabha (1873): Countered Christian/Hindu proselytization; standardized Sikh identity.
- Akālī Movement: Fought for gurdwara control (1920s).
VI. Interactions with Other Traditions
VII. Modern Developments
-
Global Diaspora
- Punjabi Diaspora: Canada (Brampton), UK (Southall), California.
- Khalistan Movement: Separatism (1980s–90s); controversial.
-
Contemporary Issues
- Caste: Ravidāsia/Valmiki sects challenge Khalsa egalitarianism.
- Gender: Female Kīrtanīe (hymn singers) gaining acceptance.
- Ecumenism: Interfaith Laṅgar at global forums.
Key Backlinks:
- Ik Oaṅkār → Contrasts with Islamic tawḥīd and Hindu saguna devotion
- Khalsa → Links to Pañj Kakkār, Martyrdom
- Guru Granth Sahib → Incorporation of Bhagat poetry (syncretism)
- Laṅgar vs. Hindu prasāda: Communal meal vs. deity offering
Contrasts Summary
Aspect | Sikhism | Hinduism | Islam |
---|---|---|---|
Ultimate Reality | Nirguṇa Brahman (formless) | Both nirguṇa/saguṇa | Allah (utterly transcendent) |
Authority | Guru Granth Sahib | Vedas + sectarian texts | Qur’an/Hadith |
Social Order | Rejects caste; gender equality | Caste integral (traditionally) | Gender roles defined |
Liberation Path | Nām Simran + righteous action | Yoga/Bhakti/Jñāna | Submission (islām) |
Afterlife | Merge with God (no rebirth) | Rebirth until mokṣa | Heaven/Hell |
Comprehensive MOC: Minor & Synthetic Traditions of India
I. Minor Hindu Sects
-
Gāṇapatya (Gaṇeśa Worship)
- Theology: Gaṇeśa as supreme Brahman (Gaṇeśa Purāṇa)
- Sects:
- Mahā-Gāṇapatya: Monistic (Gaṇeśa = Nirguṇa Brahman)
- Pūrṇa-Gāṇapatya: Dualistic devotion
- Practices: Gaṇeśa Caturthī festival; chanting Gāṇapati Atharvaśīrṣa
-
Saura (Sun Cult)
- Texts: Saura Purāṇa, Sāmba Purāṇa
- Temples: Konark (Odisha), Modhera (Gujarat)
- Rituals: Sūrya Namaskāra at dawn; copper idol worship
-
Nāga Traditions
- Serpent Worship: Ananta (cosmic serpent) as Śeṣa
- Festivals: Nāga Pañcamī; offerings at anthills
- Syncretism: Merged with Dravidian folk traditions
II. Syncretic Bhakti Movements
-
Sant Mat (13th–18th c.)
Saint Tradition Key Teachings Kabīr Nirguṇa Bhakti Rejected caste/idols; Bijak poetry Nānak Early Sikhism ”No Hindu, no Muslim” (Ik Oaṅkār) Mīrābāī Kṛṣṇa Bhakti Gender-transcending devotion Dādū Dayāl Rājasthānī Sants Universal path (Sahaja Yoga) -
Baul Tradition (Bengal)
- Syncretism: Hindu Tantra + Sufi mysticism
- Practice: Ecstatic singing (Baul Gān); rejection of orthodoxy
-
Ravidāsia Movement
- Founder: Guru Ravidas (Śudra poet in Guru Granth)
- Modern Form: Separate religion (Amritdhari ceremonies)
III. Reformist Movements
-
Arya Samaj (1875)
- Founder: Dayananda Saraswati
- Tenets:
- “Back to Vedas” (reject Purāṇas)
- Śuddhi (reconversion)
- Social reform (widow remarriage, anti-caste)
-
Brahmo Samaj (1828)
- Founders: Raja Ram Mohan Roy, Debendranath Tagore
- Theology: Unitarian Hinduism; rejected avatāras, idolatry
- Legacy: Precursor to Indian Renaissance
-
Prārthanā Samāj (1867)
- Focus: Monotheism + social service (Mumbai-based)
- Leader: M. G. Ranade
IV. Neo-Vedānta & Global Movements
-
Ramakrishna Mission (1897)
- Founders: Ramakrishna (mystic), Vivekananda (philosopher)
- Teachings:
- “All religions true” (Jātā Mat, Tāṭh Path)
- Practical Vedānta (Daridra Nārāyaṇa Seva)
-
- Integral Yoga: Synthesis of Vedānta + evolution theory
- Supermind: Divine consciousness transforming matter
-
ISKCON (1966)
- Globalized Gauḍīya Vaiṣṇavism; Kṛṣṇa Consciousness movement
-
- Syncretic worship: Śiva-Śakti + Sai Baba of Shirdi
- Sarva Dharma Symbol: Unified emblem
V. Tribal & Folk Traditions
-
- Grāmadevatā: Village goddesses (e.g., Mariamman – smallpox)
- Bhūta Kola: Spirit worship (Karnataka)
-
- Deities: Marang Buru (supreme), Jaher Era (forest spirit)
- Rituals: Sohrai harvest festival; sacred groves
-
- Meitei tradition: Sanamahism + Vaiṣṇavism
- Donyi-Polo (Arunachal): Sun-Moon animism + Tibetan Buddhism
VI. Political Hinduism
-
- Founders: V. D. Savarkar (1923), M. S. Golwalkar
- Tenets:
- India = Hindu nation (Pitṛbhūmi + Punyabhūmi)
- Rām Janmabhūmi movement (Ayodhya)
- Groups: Rashtriya Swayamsevak Sangh (RSS), Vishva Hindu Parishad (VHP), Bajrang Dal
-
Critics & Alternatives
- Gandhian Sarvodaya: Hindu-Muslim unity
- Ambedkarite Buddhism: Dalit liberation movement
VII. New Religious Movements
-
- Teachings: Soul consciousness; Murli meditations
- Millenarianism: Coming destruction → Golden Age
-
- “Zorba the Buddha”: Materialism + mysticism fusion
- Controversies: Rajneeshpuram commune
-
- Sudarshan Kriyā breathing technique + Vedic philosophy
Key Backlinks:
- Sant Mat → Links to Kabīr/Nānak’s anti-ritualism
- Arya Samaj vs. Brahmo Samaj: Vedic revival vs. rational theism
- Neo-Vedānta → Vivekananda’s Parliament of Religions impact
- Hindutva ↔ Gandhian: Competing visions of Hinduism
Contrasts Summary
Tradition | Theology | Social Stance | Political Role |
---|---|---|---|
Sant Mat | Nirguṇa bhakti (formless God) | Anti-caste | Quietist |
Arya Samaj | Vedic monotheism | Reformist (anti-child marriage) | Hindu nationalism catalyst |
Neo-Vedānta | Universal Vedānta | Philanthropic | Cultural diplomacy |
Hindutva | Hindu primacy | Majoritarian | Electoral politics |
Tribal | Animism + absorption | Community-centric | Autonomy movements |
Comprehensive MOC: Political Hinduism & Hindutva
I. Ideological Foundations
-
Core Texts
- Hindutva: Who is a Hindu? (1923): V. D. Savarkar’s definition – “Hindu = Pitṛbhūmi (fatherland) + Punyabhūmi (holy land)”
- Bunch of Thoughts (1966): M. S. Golwalkar – Advocates “Hindu Rāṣṭra” (nation) with minorities subordinated
- We, or Our Nationhood Defined (1939): Golwalkar – Praises Nazi racial purity
-
Key Concepts
- Cultural Nationalism: India as inherently Hindu civilization (vs. secular territorial nationalism)
- Akhaṇḍ Bhārata: Undivided India (pre-1947 borders) as sacred geography
- Śuddhi + Saṅgathan: Reconversion + unity movements against Islam/Christianity
- Hindu Samāj: Organic social order (varṇāśrama) over Western individualism
II. Historical Evolution
Phase | Events/Leaders | Milestones |
---|---|---|
Pre-Independence (1920s–1947) | Keshav Baliram Hedgewar (RSS founder) | 1925: Rashtriya Swayamsevak Sangh (RSS) established in Nagpur |
Syama Prasad Mukherjee | 1951: Founded Bharatiya Jana Sangh (BJS) | |
Underground (1948–1975) | RSS banned after Gandhi assassination | Deendayal Upadhyaya articulates Integral Humanism (1965) |
Resurgence (1980s–90s) | Ram Janmabhoomi Movement | 1990: L. K. Advani’s Rāth Yātrā; 1992: Babri Masjid demolition |
Political Power (1998–Present) | Atal Bihari Vajpayee (PM 1998–2004) | 2002: Gujarat riots under Narendra Modi |
Narendra Modi (PM 2014–Present) | 2019: Abrogation of Article 370; CAA-NRC protests |
III. Major Organizations
Organization | Founded | Role | Key Figures |
---|---|---|---|
Rashtriya Swayamsevak Sangh (RSS) (Rāṣṭrīya Svayamsevak Saṅgh) | 1925 | Ideological nucleus; paramilitary śākhās | Mohan Bhagwat (current chief) |
BJP (Bhāratīya Janatā Party) | 1980 | Political wing | Amit Shah, Yogi Adityanath |
Vishva Hindu Parishad (VHP) (Viśva Hindū Pariṣad) | 1964 | Religious mobilization | Ashok Singhal (historic) |
Bajrang Dal | 1984 | Youth vigilantes | Vinay Katiyar |
ABVP (Akhil Bhāratīya Vidyārthī Pariṣad) | 1948 | Student wing | Sunil Ambekar |
IV. Political Theology
-
Sacralization of Nation
- Bhārat Mātā: Mother India as goddess (temples in Haridwar/Varanasi)
- Tīrtha Sthāns as National Symbols:
- Rām Janmabhūmi (Ayodhya) → Reclaimed as temple (2024 consecration)
- Kṛṣṇa Janmabhūmi (Mathura) & Kāśī Viśvanāth (Varanasi) – next targets
-
Mytho-Historical Claims
- Indigenous Aryans: Rejects Aryan migration theory; Vedic continuity since 10,000 BCE
- Saffronization of Education: NCERT textbooks emphasizing “Hindu golden age”
-
Enemy Theology
- External Threats: “Abrahamic religions” (Islam/Christianity) as colonial impositions
- Internal Threats: “Pseudo-secularists” (Congress), “Urban Naxals” (left intellectuals)
V. Electoral Strategies
- Sampark Kranti (Contact Revolution): RSS-BJP grassroots mobilization
- Labhārthī Varg (Beneficiary Politics): Welfare schemes branded as “Modi ki Guarantee”
- Pasmanda Outreach: Wooing backward-caste Muslims against Ashraf elite
- Social Engineering: OBC/SC/ST inclusion (e.g., Ram Nath Kovind as President)
VI. Controversies & Conflicts
- Mob Lynching: Anti-cow slaughter violence (2015–present; Pehlu Khan case)
- Love jihad conspiracy theory: Conspiracy theory interfaith marriages as conversion plots
- Ghar Wapsi: Mass reconversion ceremonies (UP, MP)
- Sedition Charges: Against activists (e.g., Stan Swamy, Umar Khalid)
VII. Global Dimensions
- Diaspora Networks:
- Overseas Friends of BJP (US/UK)
- Hindu Swayamsevak Sangh (HSS) – international RSS
- Soft Power Diplomacy:
- International Yoga Day (UN adoption)
- Vedic Science promotion (e.g., AIIMS adding Sushruta in curriculum)
VIII. Critiques & Counter-Movements
-
Secular Critiques:
- “Constitutional betrayal” (Preamble’s socialist/secular ideals)
- Hate Speech normalization (e.g., Yogi Adityanath’s “Abba Jaan” remark)
-
Dalit-Bahujan Resistance:
- Bhima Koregaon protests (2018)
- Charter of Demands: Land rights, anti-caste laws
-
Islamic Responses:
- All India Muslim Personal Law Board defending mosques
- Pasmanda Muslim Mahaz challenging Hindutva’s Muslim outreach
Key Backlinks:
- Savarkar → Hindutva definition vs. Gandhi’s Ram Rajya
- Babri Masjid → Archaeological Survey of India reports as political tools
- CAA-NRC → Exclusionary citizenship theology
- Saffron → Color symbolism from renunciation to power
Contrasts with Gandhian Hinduism
Aspect | Hindutva | Gandhian Hinduism |
---|---|---|
Nationalism | Ethnic-religious (Hindu Rashtra) | Territorial (Sarvodaya) |
Violence | Justified for defense (Kshatra Dharma) | Absolute Ahimsā |
Minorities | Assimilate or subordinate | Equal respect (Sarva Dharma Sambhava) |
Caste | Integrate OBC/SC under Hindu unity | Annihilate caste (Harijan uplift) |
Economics | Capitalist growth + Hindu charity | Village self-sufficiency |
- Regional Studies: Hindutva in Kerala vs. UP
- Gender Dynamics: Rashtra Sevika Samiti vs. Love jihad conspiracy theory narratives
- Comparative: Hindutva vs. Zionism/Buddhist Nationalism