Tawassul and Istighatha

Tawassul (intercession or seeking a means to Allah) and Istighatha (seeking help from other than Allah) are areas of significant ikhtilaf (disagreement) among various Islamic schools of thought. The debate primarily revolves around their permissibility, limits, and methodologies. Below is a comparative analysis of how different groups approach these concepts:

1. The Barelvi Perspective

Tawassul: Barelvi scholars generally endorse the practice of tawassul through the Prophet Muhammad (PBUH), righteous individuals, or saints (Awliya). They cite hadiths and practices of companions that involve seeking blessings through the Prophet and his supplications, even posthumously. For instance, the hadith of the blind man who sought the Prophet’s intercession is often referenced.
Istighatha: They allow calling upon saints or the Prophet for help in ways that acknowledge Allah as the ultimate source of aid. The requests to saints are considered a means, not an alternative to Allah’s power.
Justification: Emphasis on Allah granting His chosen servants powers as intermediaries, in line with Quranic verses such as 5:35 (“Seek the means to Allah”).

2. The Deobandi Perspective

Tawassul: Deobandis generally accept tawassul if it involves asking Allah directly using the status of the Prophet or righteous people as a means. However, they strongly oppose invoking the deceased or seeking their help directly.
Istighatha: They consider it shirk (associating partners with Allah) if one calls upon anyone other than Allah for direct aid, especially those who have passed away, as they no longer have worldly agency.
Justification: Their stance is rooted in upholding Tawhid (monotheism) and emphasizing Allah’s exclusive authority over all matters.

3. The Wahhabi/Salafi Perspective

Tawassul: This group permits only specific forms of tawassul, such as asking Allah by His names, attributes, or through one’s good deeds. They categorically reject any invocation that involves the deceased, citing it as an innovation (bid’ah) or shirk.
Istighatha: Strongly prohibited, as it is viewed as usurping Allah’s sole power to grant help. They reference Quranic verses like 10:106, where Allah warns against invoking others besides Him.
Justification: Strict adherence to Tawhid and rejection of practices seen as resembling pre-Islamic polytheistic customs.

4. Sufi Orders

Tawassul: Sufi traditions embrace tawassul as a spiritual practice, using the intercession of saints and prophets as a means to seek closeness to Allah. This is seen as a means of barakah (blessings) and spiritual connection.
Istighatha: Similar to Barelvi thought, Sufis often view istighatha as permissible within a framework that maintains Allah as the ultimate helper. It is believed that saints, as manifestations of Allah’s will, can assist through divine permission.
Justification: Heavy reliance on mystical interpretations of Quranic verses and Prophetic traditions to justify these practices.

5. Shia Perspective

Tawassul: Integral to Shia theology, with tawassul being widely practiced through the Ahlul Bayt (family of the Prophet). They emphasize seeking intercession from figures like Imam Ali, Fatimah, and other Imams.
Istighatha: It is generally permissible in Shia Islam to seek help from Imams, as they are believed to have divine authority and closeness to Allah.
Justification: Shia doctrine of Imamate supports the idea that Imams are divinely guided and can act as intermediaries between Allah and the believers.

Points Of Ikhtilaf

Interpretation of Tawhid:
- Wahhabi/Salafi scholars argue that invoking others compromises pure monotheism.
- Barelvi, Shia, and Sufi scholars argue that seeking intercession aligns with Allah’s will and divine permission.
Understanding Hadith and Practice of the Salaf:
- Groups differ on interpreting hadiths about companions seeking blessings through the Prophet or supplications involving intermediaries.
Agency of the Deceased:
- A key point of contention is whether deceased individuals can intercede or assist the living, with Wahhabi/Salafi scholars denying this outright, while others argue it is through Allah’s permission.
Scope of Bid’ah:
- Wahhabi/Salafi scholars classify many forms of tawassul and istighatha as innovations, while others view them as extensions of permissible Islamic practices.

The differences in dua reflect underlying theological positions on Tawhid (monotheism), agency of intermediaries, and the concept of barakah (blessings).

1. Barelvi Example

“Ya Rasul Allah, I turn to you as my intercessor before Allah, asking for your mercy and aid through the blessings Allah has granted you. O Beloved of Allah, grant me your intercession by the permission of Allah.”

Explanation:

Intercession: They include direct references to the Prophet Muhammad (PBUH) or saints, asking for their help to seek Allah’s mercy.
Belief: The Prophet and saints are spiritually alive and can serve as a wasilah (means) to Allah’s assistance.

2. Deobandi Example

“O Allah, I ask You by the love and rank of Your Prophet, Muhammad (PBUH), to fulfill my need. Grant me mercy and forgive my sins. Ameen.”

Explanation:

Intercession: They prefer asking Allah directly, using the status of the Prophet or righteous people as a reference point.
Belief: Direct invocation of Allah is emphasized, and tawassul through the living Prophet is preferred over the deceased.

3. Wahhabi/Salafi Example

“O Allah, I seek Your help alone. You are the All-Powerful and All-Merciful. Grant me what is best for me, and keep me steadfast on Your path. Ameen.”

Explanation:

Intercession: Avoids mentioning intermediaries like the Prophet or saints.
Belief: Supplications should be directed exclusively to Allah without involving others, even as intermediaries, based on strict adherence to Tawhid.

4. Sufi Example

“Ya Allah, by the light of Your beloved Prophet, Muhammad (PBUH), and the blessings of the Awliya (friends of Allah), grant me relief from my trials. Allow their intercession to bring me closer to Your mercy.”

Explanation:

Intercession: Involves invoking both Allah and spiritually significant figures like the Prophet or saints.
Belief: Saints are seen as conduits for divine mercy and blessings, acting with Allah’s permission.

5. Shia Example

“O Allah, for the sake of Muhammad and the family of Muhammad, forgive me, grant me ease, and guide me on the straight path. O Imam Ali, help me find the path to Allah’s guidance through your wisdom.”

Explanation:

Intercession: Includes specific invocations to the Ahlul Bayt (family of the Prophet), acknowledging their spiritual rank and closeness to Allah.
Belief: The Imams are divinely appointed figures who can intercede on behalf of believers.

Element	Barelvi	Deobandi	Wahhabi/Salafi	Sufi	Shia
Direct Invocation of Allah	Yes, with intermediaries	Yes, sometimes with reference to status	Exclusively Allah	Yes, with intermediaries	Yes, with intermediaries
Reference to Prophet	Direct and explicit	Indirect	No	Direct and explicit	Direct and explicit
Reference to Saints/Imams	Yes	No	No	Yes	Yes (Imams specifically)
Use of Wasilah (Means)	Central	Accepted but limited	Rejected	Central	Central

Tawassul and Istighatha

1. The Barelvi Perspective

Tawassul: Barelvi scholars generally endorse the practice of tawassul through the Prophet Muhammad (PBUH), righteous individuals, or saints (Awliya). They cite hadiths and practices of companions that involve seeking blessings through the Prophet and his supplications, even posthumously. For instance, the hadith of the blind man who sought the Prophet’s intercession is often referenced.
Istighatha: They allow calling upon saints or the Prophet for help in ways that acknowledge Allah as the ultimate source of aid. The requests to saints are considered a means, not an alternative to Allah’s power.
Justification: Emphasis on Allah granting His chosen servants powers as intermediaries, in line with Quranic verses such as 5:35 (“Seek the means to Allah”).

2. The Deobandi Perspective

Tawassul: Deobandis generally accept tawassul if it involves asking Allah directly using the status of the Prophet or righteous people as a means. However, they strongly oppose invoking the deceased or seeking their help directly.
Istighatha: They consider it shirk (associating partners with Allah) if one calls upon anyone other than Allah for direct aid, especially those who have passed away, as they no longer have worldly agency.
Justification: Their stance is rooted in upholding Tawhid (monotheism) and emphasizing Allah’s exclusive authority over all matters.

3. The Wahhabi/Salafi Perspective

Tawassul: This group permits only specific forms of tawassul, such as asking Allah by His names, attributes, or through one’s good deeds. They categorically reject any invocation that involves the deceased, citing it as an innovation (bid’ah) or shirk.
Istighatha: Strongly prohibited, as it is viewed as usurping Allah’s sole power to grant help. They reference Quranic verses like 10:106, where Allah warns against invoking others besides Him.
Justification: Strict adherence to Tawhid and rejection of practices seen as resembling pre-Islamic polytheistic customs.

4. Sufi Orders

Tawassul: Sufi traditions embrace tawassul as a spiritual practice, using the intercession of saints and prophets as a means to seek closeness to Allah. This is seen as a means of barakah (blessings) and spiritual connection.
Istighatha: Similar to Barelvi thought, Sufis often view istighatha as permissible within a framework that maintains Allah as the ultimate helper. It is believed that saints, as manifestations of Allah’s will, can assist through divine permission.
Justification: Heavy reliance on mystical interpretations of Quranic verses and Prophetic traditions to justify these practices.

5. Shia Perspective

Tawassul: Integral to Shia theology, with tawassul being widely practiced through the Ahlul Bayt (family of the Prophet). They emphasize seeking intercession from figures like Imam Ali, Fatimah, and other Imams.
Istighatha: It is generally permissible in Shia Islam to seek help from Imams, as they are believed to have divine authority and closeness to Allah.
Justification: Shia doctrine of Imamate supports the idea that Imams are divinely guided and can act as intermediaries between Allah and the believers.

Points Of Ikhtilaf

Interpretation of Tawhid:
- Wahhabi/Salafi scholars argue that invoking others compromises pure monotheism.
- Barelvi, Shia, and Sufi scholars argue that seeking intercession aligns with Allah’s will and divine permission.
Understanding Hadith and Practice of the Salaf:
- Groups differ on interpreting hadiths about companions seeking blessings through the Prophet or supplications involving intermediaries.
Agency of the Deceased:
- A key point of contention is whether deceased individuals can intercede or assist the living, with Wahhabi/Salafi scholars denying this outright, while others argue it is through Allah’s permission.
Scope of Bid’ah:
- Wahhabi/Salafi scholars classify many forms of tawassul and istighatha as innovations, while others view them as extensions of permissible Islamic practices.

The differences in dua reflect underlying theological positions on Tawhid (monotheism), agency of intermediaries, and the concept of barakah (blessings).

1. Barelvi Example

“Ya Rasul Allah, I turn to you as my intercessor before Allah, asking for your mercy and aid through the blessings Allah has granted you. O Beloved of Allah, grant me your intercession by the permission of Allah.”

Explanation:

Intercession: They include direct references to the Prophet Muhammad (PBUH) or saints, asking for their help to seek Allah’s mercy.
Belief: The Prophet and saints are spiritually alive and can serve as a wasilah (means) to Allah’s assistance.

2. Deobandi Example

“O Allah, I ask You by the love and rank of Your Prophet, Muhammad (PBUH), to fulfill my need. Grant me mercy and forgive my sins. Ameen.”

Explanation:

Intercession: They prefer asking Allah directly, using the status of the Prophet or righteous people as a reference point.
Belief: Direct invocation of Allah is emphasized, and tawassul through the living Prophet is preferred over the deceased.

3. Wahhabi/Salafi Example

“O Allah, I seek Your help alone. You are the All-Powerful and All-Merciful. Grant me what is best for me, and keep me steadfast on Your path. Ameen.”

Explanation:

Intercession: Avoids mentioning intermediaries like the Prophet or saints.
Belief: Supplications should be directed exclusively to Allah without involving others, even as intermediaries, based on strict adherence to Tawhid.

4. Sufi Example

“Ya Allah, by the light of Your beloved Prophet, Muhammad (PBUH), and the blessings of the Awliya (friends of Allah), grant me relief from my trials. Allow their intercession to bring me closer to Your mercy.”

Explanation:

Intercession: Involves invoking both Allah and spiritually significant figures like the Prophet or saints.
Belief: Saints are seen as conduits for divine mercy and blessings, acting with Allah’s permission.

5. Shia Example

“O Allah, for the sake of Muhammad and the family of Muhammad, forgive me, grant me ease, and guide me on the straight path. O Imam Ali, help me find the path to Allah’s guidance through your wisdom.”

Explanation:

Intercession: Includes specific invocations to the Ahlul Bayt (family of the Prophet), acknowledging their spiritual rank and closeness to Allah.
Belief: The Imams are divinely appointed figures who can intercede on behalf of believers.

Element	Barelvi	Deobandi	Wahhabi/Salafi	Sufi	Shia
Direct Invocation of Allah	Yes, with intermediaries	Yes, sometimes with reference to status	Exclusively Allah	Yes, with intermediaries	Yes, with intermediaries
Reference to Prophet	Direct and explicit	Indirect	No	Direct and explicit	Direct and explicit
Reference to Saints/Imams	Yes	No	No	Yes	Yes (Imams specifically)
Use of Wasilah (Means)	Central	Accepted but limited	Rejected	Central	Central

published

modified

reading time

Tag

Tawassul and Istighatha

1. The Barelvi Perspective

2. The Deobandi Perspective

3. The Wahhabi/Salafi Perspective

4. Sufi Orders

5. Shia Perspective

Points Of Ikhtilaf

1. Barelvi Example

2. Deobandi Example

3. Wahhabi/Salafi Example

4. Sufi Example

5. Shia Example

You might like the following